A landmark case is unfolding in the New York State Supreme Court that could upend the concept of property rights for crypto assets. The defendant, operating under the pseudonym John Doe 33, has filed a motion to dismiss a lawsuit filed on March 11 on behalf of Noah Doe and two Wyoming-based companies — ABC Company and XYZ Company. The plaintiffs seek to claim ownership of 39,069 inactive Bitcoin addresses containing, by various estimates, between 3.7 and 3.8 million BTC. At the current exchange rate, this amounts to approximately $231 billion.

The list of these addresses includes wallets publicly associated with Bitcoin's creator, Satoshi Nakamoto, as well as the legendary address 1Feex, linked to the Mt. Gox exchange hack. The identity of the private key controller for 1Feex remains unknown.

Legal Conflict: Bitcoin Address as "Abandoned Property"

The plaintiffs base their argument on Article 7-B of New York State's personal property law. They claim that inactive wallets constitute abandoned property, whose owners did not respond after notification. However, John Doe 33, acting as the defendant, insists that Bitcoin addresses are not legal entities that can be sued. Furthermore, he argues that the plaintiffs effectively handed over their own USB drives containing public blockchain data to the police, which does not provide grounds for recognizing the addresses as found property.

According to Galaxy Research head Alex Thorn, John Doe 33 is linked to a wallet holding 5,000 BTC that has not moved since April 2014 — over 12 years. Thorn emphasizes that the emergence of a real defendant contesting the lawsuit fundamentally changes the dynamics of the case: "He is pointing out precisely those jurisdictional and legislative flaws that are hardest for the plaintiffs to circumvent." Until now, the case had been proceeding against a list of addresses whose owners did not appear in court, giving the plaintiffs an opportunity to obtain a ruling without a full adversarial position.

Inactivity ≠ Abandonment of Property

According to Bitbo data, approximately 3.5 million BTC have not moved in over 10 years, and another 6.6 million have not moved in over five years. Such prolonged inactivity could be explained either by the loss of private keys or by intentional storage in cold wallets. In the event of the owner's death, access to the funds may depend on inheritance — a complex and often unresolvable process.

Bitcoin lawyer Ian Cohen, who filed an amicus curiae brief with the court, urged the dismissal of the lawsuit, stating: "Simple inactivity, no matter how long, does not constitute abandonment of property." He also noted that New York State's abandoned property law, amended in 2022 for virtual currencies, provides for the transfer of such assets to the state comptroller, not to private individuals or companies.

Cryptalist Analytical Commentary: This lawsuit is not merely a legal oddity but a direct attack on the fundamental principle of cryptocurrencies: "not your keys, not your coins." If the court recognizes prolonged inactivity as grounds for transferring rights, it would create a dangerous precedent. Any large inactive wallet, including Satoshi's addresses, could become the target of legal claims. However, John Doe 33's decision to appear in court sends a powerful signal to the market: owners of "sleeping" coins are ready to defend their rights, and any attempt to seize their assets without a fight will not succeed. For now, this case is the most striking example of how traditional jurisprudence clashes with the decentralized nature of Bitcoin. The outcome could determine the future of crypto inheritance regulation for years to come.