The high-profile case involving 39,069 inactive Bitcoin addresses, which could have set a dangerous precedent for the entire industry, has taken an unexpected turn. The pseudonymous defendant John Doe 33 has filed a motion with the New York Supreme Court to dismiss the lawsuit filed on March 11 on behalf of Noah Doe and two Wyoming LLCs. The plaintiffs seek to claim ownership of approximately 3.8 million BTC — a staggering $231 billion at current exchange rates.

Legal Nonsense: Can a Public Blockchain Be "Found"?

The plaintiffs' claims are based on New York State's abandoned property law. They argue that inactive wallets constitute "found" property, whose owners did not come forward after notification. However, John Doe 33's defense delivers a crushing blow to this logic. The defendant points to a fundamental legal error: Bitcoin addresses are not individuals or legal entities that can be sued. Moreover, he states that the plaintiffs essentially handed over their own USB drives containing public blockchain data to the police, which does not create a basis for recognizing the addresses as "found property."

Galaxy's Head of Research, Alex Thorn, rightly notes that the emergence of a real defendant who challenges the lawsuit and points out jurisdictional flaws completely upends the case. Previously, the plaintiffs could have relied on a default judgment, as the address owners did not appear in court. John Doe 33, linked to a wallet holding 5,000 BTC ($300 million), is not asking to be removed from the case — he insists the entire lawsuit is legally void.

Long-Term Inactivity Is Not Abandonment of Property

This case exposes a deep misunderstanding of the nature of crypto assets. Approximately 3.5 million BTC have not moved for over a decade. Such coins are either permanently lost or held in cold wallets by investors who intentionally refrain from making transactions. As Bitcoin lawyer Ian Cohen rightly noted in his amicus curiae brief, "mere inactivity, no matter how long, is not abandonment of property." New York's abandoned property law, amended in 2022 for virtual currencies, provides for the transfer of such assets to the state comptroller, not to private individuals.

My analysis: This lawsuit is a blatant attempt at legal looting that, if successful, would create chaos in the industry. Anyone could "find" an old Satoshi address and claim rights to it. Fortunately, the judicial system is beginning to understand that the blockchain is not a treasure map but a public ledger, and it is impossible to "find" someone else's private key. The emergence of John Doe 33 is not just about protecting the interests of one holder; it is about defending the very principle of property rights for digital assets. The Salomon Brothers case, which previously attempted to use OP_RETURN for similar purposes, only confirms that the industry must be prepared for such attacks.