The high-profile case concerning claims to 39,069 long-inactive bitcoin addresses, containing an estimated 3.7 to 3.8 million BTC (over $230 billion at current exchange rates), has taken an unexpected and likely fatal turn. The pseudonymous defendant, identified in court documents as John Doe 33, has filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit, arguing that the entire legal framework of the plaintiffs is baseless.

Let me recap the essence of the claims: the plaintiff Noah Doe and two Wyoming-registered companies (ABC Company and XYZ Company) petitioned the New York Supreme Court, asserting that the bitcoins in these addresses constitute "abandoned property." They base their position on Article 7-B of the local personal property law, which governs found property. The list includes addresses publicly associated with Satoshi Nakamoto, as well as the famous 1Feex address linked to the Mt. Gox hack.

Key Defense Argument: A Bitcoin Address Is Not a Person

In his motion, John Doe 33 pointed out a fundamental legal error by the plaintiffs. According to him, bitcoin addresses are not legal entities—they are neither individuals nor companies that can be summoned to court. He argues that the plaintiffs effectively handed over their own USB drives to the police, onto which they recorded public blockchain data. This, in his view, does not establish grounds for recognizing the addresses as found property.

John Doe 33 emphasized that he uses a pseudonym solely for security and privacy reasons, fearing physical persecution, which is standard practice for large crypto asset holders. He is not connected to the 33rd address on the plaintiffs' list.

Expert Opinion: The Case Is Changing Course

Galaxy's Head of Research, Alex Thorn, commented on the situation. He noted that John Doe 33 controls a wallet with 5,000 BTC (approximately $300 million) that has not moved since April 2014. The emergence of a real defendant who not only seeks to be excluded from the case but also proves the entire lawsuit is legally void completely changes the dynamics of the proceedings. "He is pointing out exactly the jurisdictional and legislative flaws that are hardest for the plaintiffs to overcome," Thorn wrote.

Until now, the case was proceeding against a list of addresses whose owners had not appeared in court. If no one had objected, the plaintiffs could have attempted to obtain a default judgment—without a full adversarial position from the other side. That scenario now seems unlikely.

Legal Practice: Inactivity ≠ Abandonment of Property

Bitcoin lawyer Ian Cohen previously filed an amicus curiae brief urging the court to dismiss the lawsuit. He argued that the law on found property applies to physical objects, not to the result of scanning a public blockchain. "Simple inactivity, no matter how prolonged, does not constitute abandonment of property," Cohen stated.

He also noted that New York State's abandoned property law, amended in 2022 to include virtual currencies, mandates the transfer of such assets to the state comptroller, not to private individuals.

Cryptalist Analytical Commentary: This precedent sends a powerful signal to anyone attempting to use old laws on found property to seize crypto assets. The court will likely side with the defendant, as trying to declare coins that have simply not moved as "abandoned property" is a legal speculation. Bitcoin is not a lost suitcase at a train station; it is an asset whose ownership is proven by knowledge of the private key, not by passivity. If the lawsuit is dismissed, it will become an important precedent protecting the rights of long-term holders who consciously store their funds in cold wallets.