The high-profile case over the rights to 39,069 inactive Bitcoin addresses, including wallets attributed to Satoshi Nakamoto himself, has taken an unexpected turn. The pseudonymous defendant John Doe 33 has filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit in the New York Supreme Court, and this could completely shift the balance of power.

The Essence of the Claims and the First Serious Blow

The lawsuit, filed in March on behalf of Noah Doe and two Wyoming LLCs, is based on Article 7-B of the local personal property law. The plaintiffs claim that the bitcoins in these addresses are "abandoned property" and demand they be transferred to them. This involves an astronomical sum: approximately 3.799 million BTC, or about $231 billion at current exchange rates. The list even includes the address 1Feex, linked to the Mt. Gox hack.

However, John Doe 33, who according to Galaxy analyst Alex Thorn controls a wallet with 5,000 BTC (about $300 million), stated that the entire structure of the lawsuit is legally untenable. He emphasizes that Bitcoin addresses are not individuals or legal entities that can be named as defendants. Moreover, he claims that the plaintiffs handed over their own USB drives containing recorded public blockchain data to the police, which in no way proves the fact of "finding" the property.

Why This Changes Everything

Before John Doe 33 appeared, the case was proceeding unilaterally—against a list of addresses whose owners remained silent. If no one had objected, the plaintiffs could have attempted to obtain a default judgment. Now, as Alex Thorn noted, "the appearance of one owner who contests the lawsuit and has the right to participate in the proceedings completely changes the posture of the case." The defendant is pointing precisely to the jurisdictional and legislative flaws that are hardest for the plaintiffs to circumvent.

Bitcoin attorney Ian Cohen, who previously filed an amicus curiae brief, also called for the lawsuit to be dismissed. He argues that "mere inactivity, no matter how prolonged, does not constitute an abandonment of property." Cohen reminds that New York State's abandoned property law, amended in 2022 for virtual currencies, provides for the transfer of such assets to the state comptroller, not to private individuals.

My Analysis: The Precedent the Industry Fears

This case is not just a legal curiosity. If the plaintiffs had succeeded, it would have created a dangerous precedent: anyone could claim rights to long-inactive bitcoins that technically belong to others. The fact that a real owner has come forward, willing to defend their assets in court, is the best news for everyone who holds cryptocurrency in cold storage. Prolonged inactivity is not an invitation to theft, but a sign of discipline or, in the worst case, a tragedy—but certainly not grounds for expropriation.