Renowned on-chain detective ZachXBT has sharply criticized hardware wallets, questioning their suitability for signing critical transactions and storing significant amounts of digital assets. In his analysis, he called Ledger the worst choice among leading manufacturers, pointing to systemic issues with Ledger Live updates that, in his words, disrupt the device's basic functionality.

ZachXBT emphasized that frequent and not always correct software updates for Ledger Live create risks for users, especially when dealing with large sums. Instead of traditional hardware wallets, he recommended using a separate iPhone, completely isolated from everyday tasks, for managing cryptocurrency. This approach, in his opinion, provides a higher level of security than reliance on devices that may be vulnerable due to updates or manufacturing defects.

The expert also noted that hardware wallets are generally not ideal for signing transactions requiring maximum confidentiality and reliability. His statement sparked a broad discussion in the crypto community, where many users have already expressed concern over Ledger's policies, including the controversial Ledger Recover service.

Expert opinion: ZachXBT's criticism deserves attention, especially in light of recent incidents with Ledger Live updates. However, completely abandoning hardware wallets in favor of a smartphone is a controversial decision, as the iPhone is not without its vulnerabilities, including attacks through malicious apps or iCloud compromise. In my view, the best strategy is to combine a hardware wallet with multi-signature and strict security procedures, rather than completely replacing one device with another.