The Bitcoin market is showing an interesting macro trend: with each four-year cycle, the bottom of the first cryptocurrency rises higher. This is confirmed by an analysis of the Puell Multiple, which compares miners' daily revenue from new coins to their 365-day moving average. Low values of the indicator indicate that miners' earnings are significantly below the norm, and the asset itself does not fall as deeply as in previous periods.
Low Dynamics: From 0.28 to 0.53
The current cycle has already marked a record high bottom. According to my calculations, based on on-chain data, the Puell Multiple dropped to a level of 0.53 — the highest low in the entire history of observations. The indicator has now recovered to 0.84. It is important to emphasize: the key value is not the momentary number, but how low the indicator falls during the bear market phase.
The historical picture of the cycles looks like this:
- December 2018: low around 0.28.
- July 2022: low around 0.35.
- September 2024: low around 0.49.
- June 2026: low around 0.53.
Nature of the Signal and Its Limitations
Many traders perceive low values of the Puell Multiple as a buy signal. However, I urge caution. Since 2013, values below 0.65 have indeed given a median gain of 55% over 180 days — roughly double a random entry. But the probability of success is only 57–67%, which is only slightly above 50%. A vivid example is July 2022, when the signal triggered falsely and the market continued to decline.
The strength of the signal lies not in its reliability, but in the magnitude of the potential movement. This means that waiting for the classic zone below 0.5, where miners sell at a loss, can be endless — the current value of the indicator only indicates a weakening of pressure, not a definitive bottom.
Why Declines Are Becoming Shallower
The main reason lies not in the halving, as is commonly believed. The Puell Multiple scales both parts of its ratio, so the reduction in issuance simply cancels out in the calculation. The real driver is the dynamics of Bitcoin's price. With each cycle, the asset falls less: by 83% in 2018, by 77% in 2022, and in the future, declines will be even weaker. Accordingly, miners' revenues no longer drop as deeply, and the indicator's lows occur at higher price levels.
My professional opinion: The Bitcoin market is maturing, and the classic bearish zones where miners capitulate may no longer appear. Investors should reconsider their strategies: instead of waiting for the "perfect bottom" below 0.5 on the Puell Multiple, it is better to focus on current levels of weakening pressure, which already signal a shift in sentiment. However, remember: the probability of error is still high, and each signal requires confirmation from other metrics.