The market systematically undervalues Strategy's preferred shares (ticker STRC). My in-depth analysis shows that the fair price of these securities is around $96, while they trade on the exchange at approximately $85. This creates a discount of nearly 13%, an anomaly for such a high-grade instrument.

At the root of this misconception is an incorrect interpretation of dividend yield. Many investors see that STRC pays a 12% dividend, and at the current reduced price, this figure exceeds 14%. However, this approach is flawed. It assumes that payments will be made indefinitely and under any conditions, but this is not the case. These shares have no maturity date, and the company is not obligated to repay the $100 par value. Payments continue only as long as Strategy can sustain them.

Why 14% Yield is a Trap

In June, amid a bitcoin decline, the shares fell 25% below par, creating the illusion of high yield. Experience suggests a simple rule: never evaluate a payment stream by dividing this year's coupon by today's price. The correct approach is to view STRC as a bond and consider only the payments that can realistically be received.

On Strategy's balance sheet are 843,775 BTC (approximately $54 billion) and an additional $3 billion in cash. Priority obligations (debt and senior preferred shares) consume $8 billion. Next come obligations for STRC — $10.5 billion. After covering these, $50.2 billion remains. The annual dividend volume for STRC is $1.73 billion. Even with zero growth in the company's reserves, it can sustain payments for 29 years.

Real Value: $96 vs. $85

Discounting this stream at a 12% rate yields a price of $96.30. The market price of $85.29 covers only 17 years of payments. This indicates that the market is overly pessimistic. For comparison, the more conservative STRF shares yield 10.4% annually.

The difference between $85 and $96 is precisely that 13% undervaluation. An important conclusion follows from this drawdown: buyers of the shares receive a 14% yield with the prospect of capital appreciation. Meanwhile, some market participants share the analyst's optimism. If he is right, investors get a 14% yield, and the price gradually returns to fair value. If the market is right, the discount serves as a warning: dividends could cease at any time.

Bitcoin's dynamics play a key role. According to my calculations, STRC returns to $100 when BTC rises to $80,000. At a bitcoin price of $40,000, STRC's value drops to $58. Strategy also has leverage: the company buys back the asset at $85, although the real value, in my opinion, is higher at $96. The current discount has become an effective financial lever for the company.

My professional opinion: The undervaluation of STRC is a temporary phenomenon driven by irrational fear of bitcoin's volatility. For investors with a long-term horizon, the current discount opens an attractive entry opportunity with high yield and capital appreciation potential.