A veteran of the debt market, specializing in high-risk instruments, has presented a detailed analysis of Strategy's preferred shares (STRC). His calculations indicate that the fair price of these securities is around $96, while they trade on the exchange at approximately $85. Thus, the market is pricing in excessive pessimism, creating a discount of roughly 13%.

This expert has 25 years of experience working with instruments in the high-risk category. He has revealed the details of his valuation model, which differs significantly from the commonly accepted approach.

Why the 14% Yield on STRC is a Trap for Investors

STRC pays dividends at 12% of par value. Dividing this amount by the current reduced price yields a return above 14%. This figure is often cited as attractive. However, the analyst insists that such a calculation is fundamentally flawed.

The method assumes that STRC investors will receive dividends forever, under any conditions. But there is no guarantee of this. These shares have no maturity date and no obligation to return the $100 par value. Payments continue only as long as Strategy can sustain them.

In June, amid a bitcoin decline, the shares fell 25% below par value. This is precisely what created the illusion of high yield. As the analyst rightly notes, "experience suggests a simple rule: never value a stream of payments by dividing this year's coupon by today's price."

Therefore, he evaluates STRC as a bond: counting only those payments that can realistically be received. On Strategy's balance sheet, there are 843,775 bitcoins (BTC) worth nearly $54 billion and an additional $3 billion in cash. Debt and senior preferred shares absorb $8 billion first. Next come STRC obligations totaling $10.5 billion.

29 Years of Dividends Even Without Bitcoin Growth

After covering priority obligations, the remaining funds amount to $50.2 billion. The annual dividend volume for STRC is $1.73 billion. These figures indicate the system's stability. Bitcoin growth of just 3.4% per year makes payments perpetual.

With zero growth in the company's cryptocurrency reserves, it would suffice for 29 years of payments. Discounting this stream at a 12% rate gives a price of $96.30. The market price of $85.29 covers only 17 years of payments. According to the analyst, the market is too pessimistic. For comparison, the more conservative STRF securities yield 10.4% annually.

The difference between $85 and $96 forms a 13% discount. An important conclusion follows from this drawdown: buyers of the shares receive a 14% yield with the prospect of asset appreciation. Meanwhile, some market participants share the analyst's optimism.

The current discount has become an effective financial lever for the company. The increase in cash reserves aligns with a strategy of preparing for a possible "bitcoin winter."

There is an important nuance in this analysis: the expert manages a fund whose capital is tied to the growth of these securities. Skeptics, however, maintain a critical stance, fearing a model failure with a $64 billion asset.

My professional opinion: The model of valuing STRC as a perpetual bond with discounted cash flow is the most appropriate approach for this instrument. The market is indeed overestimating the risks associated with bitcoin's volatility, forgetting the fundamental support from Strategy's massive reserves. The 13% discount is not just a number, but a signal for patient investors ready to receive stable income while awaiting cryptocurrency growth.