The market is systematically undervaluing the preferred shares of Strategy (STRC). My analysis, based on fundamental data and the company's debt structure, shows that the fair price of these securities is around $96, while current quotes fluctuate near $85. This creates a discount of almost 13% — an anomaly that experienced investors should carefully examine.
Why a 14% Yield is a Trap for the Inattentive
At first glance, STRC seems attractive: the dividend yield exceeds 14% if you divide the annual coupon by the current price. However, this approach is a gross mistake. It assumes that dividends will be paid forever and under any conditions. But that is not the case. These securities have no maturity date, and the issuer is not obligated to repay the $100 par value. Payments continue only as long as Strategy is able to sustain them.
In June, amid a Bitcoin correction, the shares fell 25% below par, creating the illusion of high yield. A true analyst should evaluate STRC like a bond: consider only the cash flows that are actually available, rather than dividing the coupon by the momentary price.
29 Years of Payments Even Without Bitcoin Growth
Let's turn to the balance sheet structure. On Strategy's balance sheet — 843,775 BTC (approximately $54 billion) plus $3 billion in cash. Priority obligations (debt and senior preferred shares) "consume" $8 billion, followed by STRC obligations of $10.5 billion. After covering all priorities, $50.2 billion in free funds remain.
The annual dividend volume for STRC is $1.73 billion. Even with zero Bitcoin growth, these reserves are sufficient for 29 years of continuous payments. Discounting this stream at a 12% rate yields a fair price of $96.30. The market, by valuing the securities at $85.29, is effectively pricing in only 17 years of payments — an extremely pessimistic scenario.
For comparison, the more conservative STRF securities yield 10.4% annually. The difference in approaches is clear.
The Path to $100 and Levers of Control
The key driver is Bitcoin's dynamics. According to my calculations, STRC's return to $100 is possible if BTC rises to $80,000. If it falls to $40,000, the price would drop to $58.
Strategy also has its own mechanisms of influence. In July 2025, STRC entered the market at $90 with a promised yield of 9%. The board of directors has already raised the rate several times — it now stands at 12%, aiming to pull the price back to par. Additionally, every extra $1 billion in reserves increases the share price by approximately 4 points, while a buyback at $85 (with a fair price of $96) adds another 5 points.
The current discount has become an effective financial lever for the company. Increasing cash reserves is preparation for a possible "Bitcoin winter."
My professional opinion: the market is too pessimistic in its valuation of STRC. The model is sustainable even under conservative assumptions. However, investors should remember: if Bitcoin stays below $40,000 for an extended period, the fragile balance could be disrupted. But at current prices and balance sheet structure, a 13% discount is not a market error, but an opportunity for those who know how to calculate.