The market systematically undervalues Strategy's (STRC) preferred shares. This is the conclusion reached by an analyst with 25 years of experience in the high-yield debt market. In his valuation model, he demonstrates that the fair price of these securities is around $96, while they trade on the exchange at approximately $85. This creates a discount of roughly 13%.

What is the root of the misconception?

The key reason for the mispricing, according to the expert, lies in an incorrect approach to calculating yield. The current dividend yield of STRC, which is 12% of the $100 par value, when divided by the reduced market price, gives an attractive 14%. However, this calculation is flawed because it implicitly assumes that dividends will be paid forever and under any conditions. This is not the case: the shares have no maturity date, and payments are not guaranteed. In June, amid a bitcoin decline, the shares fell 25% below par, creating the illusion of high yield.

"Experience suggests a simple rule: never evaluate a payment stream by dividing this year's coupon by today's price," the analyst notes. He proposes valuing STRC as a bond, considering only those payments that can realistically be made.

29 years of stability even without bitcoin growth

The analyst builds his model on the company's balance sheet. After covering priority obligations ($8 billion in debt and senior preferred shares, plus $10.5 billion in STRC obligations), $50.2 billion remains. Annual dividends on STRC amount to $1.73 billion. Even with zero growth in the company's cryptocurrency reserves, this is enough for 29 years of payments. Discounting this stream at a 12% rate yields a price of $96.30. The market price of $85.29 covers only 17 years of payments. The market, in the expert's view, is overly pessimistic. For comparison, the more conservative STRF shares yield 10.4% annually.

Conclusion: a discounted purchase or a warning?

The current 13% discount is either an opportunity or a trap. If the analyst is right, investors get a 14% yield with the prospect of the asset's price rising to fair value. If the market is right, the discount serves as a warning: dividends could cease at any moment. Notably, according to a BitcoinTreasuries survey, more than half of STRC holders used the dip below par to buy.

My view as an analyst: The discounted cash flow valuation model looks convincing, but it critically depends on the assumption of bitcoin's stability. A rise in BTC to $80,000 would return STRC to its $100 par value, while a drop to $40,000 would lower the price to $58. The company, for its part, uses the discount as a financial lever, buying back shares at $85, even though their real value, according to calculations, is higher. The strategy of accumulating cash is a prudent preparation for a possible "crypto winter." However, investors should remember: until the market believes in the sustainability of Strategy's model, the discount may persist. Skeptics, like Peter Schiff, who predicts bitcoin will fall to $20,000, add weight to this scenario.