Strategy (STRC) preferred shares are trading at a discount of about 13% to their fair value. This is the conclusion of a valuation model built on an analysis of the company's cash flows and reserves. The current market price of around $85 per share does not reflect the issuer's actual ability to generate dividend income.
The analysis is based on 25 years of experience with high-risk instruments. The expert assessment stems from the fact that the traditional method of calculating yield — dividing the annual coupon by the current price — is misleading for investors in the case of STRC.
Yes, with a par value of $100 and a dividend rate of 12%, the current yield exceeds 14%. However, this approach assumes that payments will be made indefinitely and under any conditions. This is incorrect. Preferred shares have no maturity date, and the company is not obligated to repay the par value. Payments continue only as long as Strategy is able to sustain them.
In June, amid a bitcoin decline, STRC shares fell 25% below par. This is precisely what created the illusion of high yield. But the seasoned analyst emphasizes: "Never evaluate a payment stream by dividing this year's coupon by today's price."
Real Value: $96.30
Instead of a simplified approach, a valuation method similar to bond analysis is applied. Only the cash flow that can actually be obtained is considered.
Strategy's balance sheet is impressive: 843,775 BTC (about $54 billion) and $3 billion in cash. Priority obligations — debt and senior preferred shares — "consume" $8 billion. Next come STRC obligations of $10.5 billion. After covering these, $50.2 billion remains.
The annual dividend volume for STRC is $1.73 billion. Even with zero growth in bitcoin reserves, these funds are sufficient for 29 years of payments. Discounting this stream at a 12% rate yields a price of $96.30. The market price of $85.29 covers only 17 years of payments. The market is overly pessimistic. For comparison, the more conservative STRF securities yield 10.4% annually.
The difference between $85 and $96 is precisely the 13% undervaluation. An important conclusion follows from this drawdown. If the analyst is correct, investors earn a 14% yield while the share price gradually returns to fair value. If the market is correct, the discount serves as a warning: dividends could cease at any moment.
Bitcoin's dynamics play a key role. According to calculations, STRC returns to $100 when BTC rises to $80,000. At a bitcoin price of $40,000, STRC's value falls to $58.
Strategy also has its own levers of influence. STRC entered the market in July 2025 at $90 with a promised yield of 9%. The board of directors then raised the rate several times — it now stands at 12% — to bring the price closer to par.
Free cash is also important. Each additional $1 billion in reserves increases the share price by about four points. A buyback adds another five — since the company repurchases the asset at $85, although the real value, according to the analyst, is higher at $96.
The current discount has become an effective financial lever for the company. Increasing cash reserves aligns with the strategy of preparing for a possible "bitcoin winter."
My view: The argumentation is strong, but it's important to remember the conflict of interest. The analyst manages a fund whose capital is tied to the growth of these securities. Skeptics, however, remain critical. Economist Peter Schiff predicts bitcoin will fall to $20,000, and investors fear a failure of the model with a $64 billion asset. The market does not apply a discount arbitrarily — it assesses not only reserves but also the fragility of the entire structure.