The market appears to be mispricing Strategy's preferred shares (ticker STRC). My analysis, based on fundamental data, indicates a significant discount. The current market price of these securities fluctuates around $85, while the fair value, according to my calculations, is approximately $96. Thus, we are observing an undervaluation of roughly 13%.
Why is the 14% yield misleading?
At first glance, STRC looks extremely attractive: the dividend yield is 12%, and at the current reduced price, it exceeds 14%. However, such a simplified calculation assumes that payments will be made indefinitely and under any conditions. This is fundamentally incorrect. Unlike bonds, these shares have no maturity date and no obligation to repay the $100 par value. Payments continue only as long as the company is able to provide them. The key point: in June, amid a bitcoin decline, the shares fell 25% below par, creating the illusion of high yield.
Bond-like valuation model: 29 years of payments without BTC growth
I value STRC as a perpetual debt instrument. To do this, it is necessary to consider only the pool of funds actually available for payments. Strategy's balance sheet is impressive: 843,775 BTC (approximately $54 billion) and $3 billion in cash. However, after covering priority obligations (debt and senior preferred shares totaling $8 billion) and STRC obligations of $10.5 billion, $50.2 billion remains. Annual dividends on STRC amount to $1.73 billion.
Even with zero growth in bitcoin reserves, these funds are sufficient for 29 years of payments. Discounting this stream at a 12% rate, I arrive at a fair price of $96.30. The market price of $85.29 covers only 17 years of payments, indicating excessive pessimism among market participants. For comparison, the more conservative STRF securities yield 10.4% annually.
Conclusions and outlook
The 13% discount between $85 and $96 is a key signal. If my model is correct, investors receive a 14% yield with the prospect of the asset's price rising to fair value. A bitcoin increase to $80,000, in my estimation, would return STRC to its $100 par value. The company itself is also actively influencing the situation by raising the rate from 9% to 12% and buying back shares at a discount, which is an effective financial lever.
Cryptalist's comment: However, it must be considered that this analysis is based on an optimistic scenario of bitcoin stability. Skeptics rightly point to the risk of model failure if BTC falls to $20,000. In that case, the discount would not be an opportunity but a warning of potential payment cessation. Investors should weigh the high yield against these fundamental risks.