The market systematically undervalues Strategy's preferred shares (STRC). Based on my calculations, grounded in a fundamental analysis of the company's cash flows and capital structure, the fair price of these securities is approximately $96, while they trade on the exchange around $85. This creates a 13% discount that is ignored by most market participants.
At the core of this undervaluation lies a fundamental error in assessing yield. Many investors see that STRC pays dividends at 12% of par value and divide this amount by the current reduced price, obtaining an attractive yield above 14%. However, this approach is flawed. It assumes dividends will be paid forever and under any conditions. In reality, these shares have no maturity date and no obligation to return the $100 par value. Payments are made only as long as Strategy is able to sustain them.
Real Valuation Through a Bond Approach Lens
The correct valuation method is to view STRC as a perpetual bond. Only payments that can actually be made must be considered. In June, amid a bitcoin decline, the shares fell 25% below par, creating the illusion of high yield. Experience suggests a simple rule: never evaluate a payment stream by dividing this year's coupon by today's price.
Let's break down Strategy's balance sheet. The company holds 843,775 BTC worth nearly $54 billion and an additional $3 billion in cash. Priority obligations—debt and senior preferred shares—absorb $8 billion. Next come STRC obligations totaling $10.5 billion. After covering priority obligations, $50.2 billion remains. The annual dividend volume for STRC is $1.73 billion. Even with zero bitcoin growth, these funds are sufficient for 29 years of payments. Discounting this stream at a 12% rate yields a price of $96.30. The market price of $85.29 covers only 17 years of payments. The market is overly pessimistic.
Scenarios and Conclusions
Bitcoin's dynamics play a key role. According to my calculations, STRC returns to $100 if bitcoin rises to $80,000. At a BTC price of $40,000, STRC's value drops to $58. The company also influences the market: STRC entered the market in July 2025 at $90 with a promised yield of 9%. The board of directors has raised the rate several times—it now stands at 12%—to bring the price closer to par. Free cash is also important—each additional $1 billion in reserves increases the share price by approximately four points, while a buyback adds another five.
The current discount has become an effective financial lever for the company. Increasing cash reserves aligns with the strategy of preparing for a possible "bitcoin winter." However, there is an important nuance in this analysis: those managing funds tied to the growth of these securities have an interest in an optimistic valuation. Skeptics, meanwhile, maintain a critical stance, fearing a model failure with a $64 billion asset.
My expert opinion: The market indeed undervalues STRC, but one must not forget that this is a high-risk instrument tied to bitcoin's volatility. The 13% discount is not just an arbitrage opportunity but a risk premium that the market builds into the price. Investors receive a 14% yield with the prospect of asset body growth, yet some market participants share the analysts' optimism. If bitcoin continues to rise, we will see a gradual return of the price to fair value. If the market is right, the discount serves as a warning: dividends could cease at any moment.