Recently, skeptical notes about neobanks have been increasingly heard in the crypto community and fintech sector. My analysis, based on detailed calculations from one of the leading DeFi analysts, confirms: launching your own neobank is a path to losses, not profits. Card operation costs literally "eat up" a significant portion of every dollar earned by clients.
Anatomy of Losses: What Lies Behind the Attractive Facade
Let's break down the financial model using a specific example. Take a neobank with a monthly turnover of $5 million, operating on external infrastructure. The first and most significant expense item is minimum payments to partners. Issuer, processing, and loyalty program costs range from $15,000 to $65,000 monthly.
Payment processing is no less costly. Processing and network fees "eat up" between $10,000 and $30,000 per month. Add customer service: verification, card issuance, and support require $7,000 to $26,000 monthly.
A separate and extremely painful item is disputes and fraud. Losses from disputed transactions and malicious activities amount to $17,000 to $27,000 per month. In total, these "external" card operation costs alone range from $60,000 to $160,000 per month, or 1.1–3.2% of every dollar spent by clients. And this excludes salaries, development, legal fees, bonuses, cloud infrastructure, and user acquisition costs.
Fees Don't Save the Day: Why the Math Doesn't Add Up
Part of these expenses can be covered by interchange fees. However, here lies the key problem. In Europe, consumer interchange fees are strictly capped at just 0.2–0.3%. In the US, the structure is different: $0.21 plus 0.05% of the transaction amount, with an additional $0.01 for fraud risk.
The difference in rates is colossal. For consumer debit cards in Europe, Visa's interchange fee is only 0.1–0.2%, while for commercial cards it reaches 2–3%. But even the collected fee is not fully retained by the neobank. Most such services keep about 70% of the interchange fee, with the remaining 30% going to the intermediary platform and partner bank.
As a result, the neobank's economics are challenging. Even with significant turnover, fee income barely covers card operation costs, and the figures vary greatly from region to region.
My expert opinion: The neobank market is overheated, and its "ease" is an illusion. To survive, such projects either need to scale to enormous volumes or find niche solutions, such as integration with DeFi and stablecoins, where the fee burden is fundamentally different. Without this, most neobanks are doomed to stagnation or losses.