The fintech market is experiencing a painful reality check. My detailed analysis shows that classic neobanks, despite their popularity, represent one of the most unprofitable business models in the modern economy. The core problem lies in disproportionately high operating expenses that literally "eat up" every cent earned.
Let's break down a specific example. Consider a neobank with a monthly turnover of $5 million, operating on external infrastructure. The first and most significant expense item is minimum guaranteed payments to partners. Issuer, processing, and software costs range from $15,000 to $65,000 monthly. This is just the foundation, onto which other costs are layered.
Breakdown of Operating Costs
Payment processing is another "black box" for the budget. Processing and network fees take $10,000 to $30,000 per month. Customer service, including verification, card issuance, and support, costs $7,000 to $26,000 monthly. Losses from disputed transactions and fraud, which amount to $17,000 to $27,000 per month, cannot be ignored. In total, these direct card operation costs alone reach $60,000 to $160,000 per month, or 1.1–3.2% of every dollar spent by customers.
And this is far from the full picture. It does not include team salaries, product development, legal support, customer bonuses, cloud infrastructure, or marketing for user acquisition. Add these million-dollar items, and the picture becomes truly alarming for investors.
Why Fees Don't Save the Situation
Interchange fees partially help offset these costs. However, here lies the main catch. In Europe, consumer interchange fees are strictly capped by regulators at 0.2–0.3%. In the US, the structure is different: $0.21 plus 0.05% of the transaction amount, with an additional $0.01 for fraud risk. But even the collected fee is not fully received by the neobank. About 70% of the interchange fee is taken by the intermediary platform and partner bank. The neobank itself gets only a small portion.
A clear example is the difference in rates by card type. Consumer Visa debit in Europe incurs a fee of only 0.1–0.2%, while for commercial cards it reaches 2–3%. This creates an imbalance: neobanks focused on retail customers earn pennies, while their expenses remain high.
My conclusion: The neobank economy today resembles a zero-sum game. Even with significant turnover, fee income barely covers operational costs for card transactions. Without implementing alternative revenue sources, such as premium service fees, lending, or DeFi solutions, most neobanks risk remaining unprofitable projects. The market awaits consolidation and a shift in business model—otherwise, we will see a wave of bankruptcies.