The cryptocurrency market is full of anomalies, but the current situation with the PUMP token is one of the most striking. The Pump.fun protocol, a platform for launching memecoins, has earned one and a half times more in the last 90 days than the entire Solana ecosystem. And this is in a "bear" market, when user activity is far from peak levels.

However, despite the impressive financial results, the market capitalization of the PUMP token itself is only about $800 million. For comparison, the project's price-to-sales ratio (P/S) stands at 1.3. This is an extremely low figure for such a fast-growing protocol. The project team is actively buying back tokens from the market, allocating 50% of their revenue to this, which should support the price, but it is not happening.

Why don't investors believe in Pump.fun?

The main argument of the project's supporters is its huge and loyal audience. The number of memecoin traders significantly exceeds the user base of any other crypto project. Over the past year, content creators on the platform have earned $400 million, comparable to the early successes of YouTube. Critics, however, including well-known analyst Zach Rynes from Chainlink, see fundamental problems.

Rynes points to several key points. First, the revenue of the memecoin launch platform is perceived as less sustainable compared to the revenue from Hyperliquid's perpetual contracts. Investors consider "gambling retail" an unreliable source of profit. Second, the structure of PUMP token unlocks puts pressure on the price: the team and early investors regularly withdraw large batches. Third, there is distrust of the team itself, which changed the terms of the buyback program (from 100% to 50% of revenue) without consulting token holders.

Double standards of the market

There is a clear cognitive dissonance. When the HYPE token from Hyperliquid fell by 70%, no one doubted its revenue. But as soon as it comes to Pump.fun, debates about the "reality" of the revenue begin. Traders from crypto Twitter are accustomed to complex DeFi protocols and do not understand Pump.fun's simple but highly profitable model. They have almost no dealings with small memecoins, although the revenue of both platforms is growing almost identically.

My professional opinion: Pump.fun is a classic example of an undervalued asset that suffers due to the bias of the crypto community's "elite" against memecoins. Until the team solves the communication problem and makes the tokenomics more transparent, the discount will persist. But fundamentally, it is one of the strongest cash flow generators in the industry, and sooner or later the market will realize this.