The Pump.fun protocol has demonstrated outstanding financial results, earning 1.5 times more over the last 90 days than the entire Solana blockchain. However, its native token, PUMP, continues to trade at a significant discount compared to its direct competitors. This has sparked heated debates in the crypto community: some call the asset the most undervalued on the market, while others point to fundamental risks.
Bull Arguments: Strong Fundamentals
Supporters of the project point to its impressive economics. In less than 2.5 years, Pump.fun has generated nearly $2.3 billion in revenue. The token's price-to-sales (P/S) ratio is just 1.3 — an extremely low figure for a crypto project. The team allocates 50% of revenue to token buybacks, creating constant buying pressure. Moreover, unlocks for the team and investors are minimal — significantly less than, for example, Hyperliquid. The platform's creators are already wealthy, and they have no incentive to sell at a market cap of $800 million.
Additionally, Pump.fun shows strong audience retention. Memecoin creators have earned $400 million on the platform in one year — a metric analysts compare to the early days of YouTube. The "bad vibes" surrounding the project, according to optimists, are exaggerated and come from ideologues who prefer to invest in projects without real users.
Critics' Counterarguments: Structural Issues and Distrust
Chainlink representative Zach Rynes highlighted several systemic problems. First, Pump.fun's revenue is considered less sustainable than Hyperliquid's fees: the memecoin platform targets "retail gamblers," whereas Hyperliquid generates stable income from perpetual contracts. Second, the team and investors regularly unlock large batches of tokens, putting pressure on the price. Third, the project sold both tokens and equity stakes to investors — making it unclear who ultimately captures the value created.
Particular concern surrounds the buyback policy: initially, all revenue was directed to buybacks, but now only half is, and token holders had no say in this decision. Finally, the team failed to deliver the promised airdrop, undermining trust.
Double Standards in the Market
Trader Ansem notes a paradox: when the HYPE token fell by 70%, no one questioned Hyperliquid's revenue. But PUMP is discussed almost exclusively in negative terms — due to bias against memecoins and the team's silence. Meanwhile, the revenue of both platforms is growing at nearly the same rate. Major traders from Crypto Twitter are accustomed to perpetual contracts and exchanges but have little to do with small tokens on Pump.fun — and this distorts their perception.
My analysis: Pump.fun's fundamental metrics indeed look compelling, but the trust issue remains key. Until the team establishes transparent communication and resolves structural issues with unlocks and value distribution, PUMP's discount to competitors will persist. However, with improved sentiment and a return of risk appetite, this asset could become one of the biggest upside plays in the second half of 2025.