The Pump.fun protocol is back in the spotlight, and for good reason. Over the past 90 days, it has earned 1.5 times more than the entire Solana network. However, despite these impressive numbers, the PUMP token is trading at a significant discount compared to its peers. Why is the market so skeptical?

According to analysts, even in a weak market, Pump.fun demonstrates steady revenue. The protocol's total revenue over 2.5 years has reached nearly $2.3 billion, with a price-to-sales (P/S) ratio of just 1.3. For comparison, many projects have a significantly higher ratio. The team allocates 50% of revenue to token buybacks, which should support the price. But the market seems unconvinced of this model's sustainability.

Arguments in favor: why Pump.fun is undervalued

Supporters of the project point to several key factors. First, Pump.fun's audience is enormous — there are far more memecoin traders than users of any other crypto project. Second, user retention is impressive: content creators earned $400 million on the platform in a year, comparable to YouTube's early successes. Third, the project team is already wealthy and has little incentive to sell tokens at a market cap of $800 million — their unlock schedule is smaller than Hyperliquid's.

Arguments against: structural issues and distrust

Critics, in turn, point to several fundamental problems. Chainlink representative Zach Rynes notes that Hyperliquid's revenue from perpetual contracts is more sustainable than earnings from a memecoin launch platform targeting "speculative retail." Additionally, the PUMP team and investors regularly unlock large batches of tokens, putting pressure on the price. The project sold both tokens and equity stakes to investors, creating confusion in value distribution. The buyback policy also raises questions: previously, all revenue went to buybacks, now only half, and token holders had no say in this decision.

Trader Ansem sees the root of the problem in total distrust. "The discount persists because people simply don't believe in the reality of PUMP's revenue," he notes. Meanwhile, double standards are observed: when the HYPE token dropped 70%, no one doubted Hyperliquid's revenue. PUMP is discussed almost exclusively in negative terms — due to bias against memecoins and the team's silence.

My expert opinion: The situation around Pump.fun is a classic example of the conflict between fundamental metrics and market perception. On one hand, we see a powerful revenue generator with a massive user base. On the other, there are structural risks related to the token distribution model and distrust of the team. Until the team addresses transparency issues and presents a clear development plan, the token discount will likely persist. However, if the market begins to reassess the project, the growth potential could be significant.