A market veteran and leading ETF analyst has proposed a radical scenario for 95-year-old Warren Buffett to manage his fortune. The proposal involves transferring approximately $140 billion worth of Berkshire Hathaway shares to a new government investment program for American children — Trump Accounts.

As a reminder, the program launched on July 4 as part of the "One Big Beautiful Bill" tax act. Every child born in the U.S. between 2025 and 2028 automatically receives $1,000 from the government into an account. Families can add up to $5,000 annually. Funds are invested by default in an S&P 500 index fund (ticker SPYM), with account management entrusted to Robinhood and BNY.

Why is this logical but unlikely?

The arguments in favor of such a move are compelling. First, it would help reduce the enormous wealth gap between generations. Second, children would gain real, practical experience in long-term investing, perfectly aligning with Buffett's own philosophy. Third, transferring shares under Trump Accounts is exempt from capital gains tax. Finally, if children hold Berkshire shares, it would extend the "Oracle of Omaha's" investment legacy for decades to come.

There is already a precedent: Michael and Susan Dell allocated $6.25 billion to support the program, directing $250 each to accounts of approximately 25 million children from low-income families.

However, as I see it, two insurmountable obstacles stand in the way of this idea. First, Buffett himself has already clearly outlined his plan: on July 14, he transferred about $6 billion in Berkshire shares to four family foundations, completely ignoring the Gates Foundation for the first time since 2006. He stated his intention to divest all his Berkshire shares over roughly eight years, and his path is already set through charitable structures, not government accounts.

Second, current legislation does not allow anything other than cash to be deposited into Trump Accounts. Congress has permitted investment only in U.S. index funds with fees below 0.1%. Changing this to allow share transfers would require a new law. And while Donald Trump hints at the possible addition of Bitcoin (BTC) to these accounts in the future, the path to accepting Berkshire shares as contributions appears extremely arduous.

My analysis: The idea is beautiful and symbolic, but it founders on Buffett's pragmatism and bureaucratic realities. Buffett's fortune is already allocated, and his philanthropic machine is running at full capacity. Trump Accounts, for all their merits, remain just one of many tools for now, not the ultimate destination for capital of this scale.