The recently passed CLARITY Act, which prohibits federal officials from issuing or endorsing digital assets, has sparked heated debate. However, according to leading financiers, this measure is merely a cosmetic fix that does not address the root of the problem. Anthony Scaramucci, founder of SkyBridge Capital and former White House Communications Director, called the new rules too lenient and ineffective in combating insider trading.
Scaramucci rightly points out that ethical standards should regulate all insider trading, not just cryptocurrency transactions. On CNBC, he emphasized that the core issue lies in the compensation system within the U.S. Congress. Members of Congress earn $180,000 a year, which, in his view, is too little to deter them from the temptation to profit from confidential information. As a solution, he suggests looking to Singapore's model, where government officials receive multi-million dollar salaries in exchange for strict ethical oversight.
The Pelosi Problem
Scaramucci's position is backed by telling statistics. Public trading reports show that the portfolio of former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, managed by her husband Paul, has consistently outperformed the S&P 500 index and Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway fund for many years. In 2024, Pelosi earned 70.9% compared to the benchmark's 24.9%. Her cumulative returns since 2014 exceed the index by thousands of percentage points. Congresswoman Anna Paulina Luna previously accused Pelosi of insider trading, but no formal charges were ever filed. This is a clear example of how the current system allows profiting from privileged access to information.
A Familiar Pattern
Scaramucci also recalled an attempt to weaken oversight of trading in Congress. Lawmakers once repealed transparency measures through a procedural vote to avoid broad debate. In April 2012, Congress passed the STOCK Act, banning trades based on non-public information, but a year later removed the requirement to publish employee trades in an online database, passing the amendment through unanimous consent without a roll-call vote.
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent recently proposed reinstating stricter restrictions on stock trading for lawmakers, but there is almost no time left to decide before the August recess. The updated CLARITY Act already prohibits the president and other federal officials from issuing or endorsing digital assets, but Scaramucci himself called this ethical compromise unviable from the start. It remains unclear whether Congress will apply the same approach to its own stock trades.
My expert opinion: The ban on cryptocurrencies could set a precedent for other restrictions, but getting Scaramucci's other demands approved will be difficult. Congress has resisted change for over a decade, and the CLARITY Act is essentially a diversionary tactic. Until lawmakers address the issue of low salaries and implement real ethical oversight for all government officials, insider trading in the U.S. will remain a "gray area" where the privileged few rule the roost.