The cryptocurrency market has once again found itself at the center of a debate about the nature of Bitcoin's movement. My analysis shows that historical BTC downturns have almost always coincided not with the halving calendar, but with fundamental shifts in the macroeconomic landscape. The latest data, which I have examined in detail, confirms this correlation, linking Bitcoin's price to industrial activity in the U.S. and real interest rates.

At the center of attention is a chart that I have compared with three key indicators over the period since 2012. The top line reflects the Bitcoin price on a logarithmic scale, the middle line shows the ISM Manufacturing Purchasing Managers' Index, and the bottom line represents the real yield on two-year U.S. Treasury notes.

Four bearish cycles: the same macroeconomic picture

On the chart, I have highlighted four zones corresponding to periods of Bitcoin decline: 2014–2015, 2018–2019, 2022, and the current one in 2026. Each of these downturns was accompanied by a decline in the ISM index, reflecting an economic slowdown. Simultaneously, real rates rose, putting additional pressure on risky assets, including Bitcoin.

The current downturn, in my observation, fits the same logic. It is accompanied by a sharp revision of expectations regarding Fed policy and a rise in real rates — the same factors as in past bear markets. This is a key point that many investors overlook.

Grayscale optimism: is the bottom already near?

The head of research at Grayscale leans toward an optimistic scenario. His position is clear: if the Fed refrains from further rate hikes, Bitcoin has likely already found its bottom — even though the four-year cycle theory suggests a more prolonged downturn.

Investor sentiment is now divided. Proponents of the cyclical model expect new lows and are preparing for the downturn to continue until September or October, while adherents of the macro view consider the reversal a matter of economics, not the calendar. Caution currently prevails, keeping some market participants from actively buying BTC, despite arguments that the worst is already over.

The key reference point for both sides remains the Fed. It is the regulator's decisions on rates and the resilience of the U.S. economy that will determine which of the two scenarios is closer to reality.

My expert opinion: The debate over what is primary for Bitcoin's price — the internal cycle or the external macroeconomic backdrop — is becoming increasingly relevant. I lean toward the view that macro factors already dominate. Investors should closely monitor inflation data and Fed rhetoric, rather than the halving calendar. This is what will determine whether the bottom has been passed or whether another wave of decline awaits us.