Blockstream CEO Adam Back sharply criticized the BIP-110 initiative, calling its supporters an "idiocracy." At the center of the dispute is a proposal to activate an update through the "flip the bit" mechanism, which aims to limit the volume of non-financial data on the Bitcoin network.

BIP-110 requires mandatory support from a majority of miners by early August 2026. However, as Back emphasized, if such support is not achieved, nothing will change for the Bitcoin mainnet. According to him, the signal will simply expire, and no consequences will follow.

The "Flip the Bit" Scheme: What Developers Propose

Representatives from Start9, which supports BIP-110, claim that implementing the changes does not carry significant risks. They call this step a "routine reconnaissance by fire" and estimate that the flip the bit signal would cost miners approximately 0.1% of annual revenue. However, Start9 also warns of potential negative consequences: without activation, there is a real risk of a blockchain split, as well as possible "stalling" of Lightning Network channels and financial losses for users.

The new rule was created to combat the Ordinals protocol, whose critics argue that heavy images and text files overload the blockchain. Back completely dismissed Start9's arguments, insisting that without broad support, the signal simply will not work. This dispute is a continuation of long-standing debates surrounding the name Satoshi Nakamoto: Back previously publicly refuted claims that the creator of Bitcoin would support such restrictions.

Technical Objections: Consensus Under the IETF Standard

Back states that technical objections cannot be ignored, calling the behavior of BIP-110 supporters "going in circles." The expert insists on the need for genuine consensus under the IETF standard, where only technically sound arguments are considered. In his view, any attempts at sabotage are irrelevant to development.

Tensions escalated after the removal of data volume restrictions in OP_RETURN from Bitcoin Core. Previously, this limit helped combat extraneous information in blocks. Strategy co-founder Michael Saylor previously expressed similar concerns about the risk of losing Bitcoin's neutrality, noting that such changes could undermine the protocol's basic principles. Conversely, some developers view the conflict as part of an old debate about spam—what kind of load the Bitcoin blockchain should fundamentally bear.

Weak Miner Support Ahead of the Deadline

Currently, there are almost no signals in favor of BIP-110. Major mining pools have not yet participated in the vote. Exchanges and node operators are closely watching the deadlines, as a contentious activation could lead to a chain split that they would have to support. Back previously refuted claims of an inevitable fork due to miners and refused to support ideas about forcibly disconnecting participants from the network.

My expert conclusion: BIP-110 is not just a technical proposal but a litmus test for the entire Bitcoin community. The conflict between "purists" (like Back) and "pragmatists" (like Start9) exposes a fundamental question: should Bitcoin remain exclusively a payment network, or can it adapt to new data formats? For now, the market and miners are voting with their feet—and their silence speaks louder than any arguments. Without broad consensus, any attempts at a "forced" update are doomed to fail, and this is correct from a decentralization standpoint.