A federal judge has issued a temporary injunction blocking Minnesota's law criminalizing prediction markets. The ruling, handed down just days before the law was set to take effect on August 1, marks a significant victory for Kalshi, Polymarket US, and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC).

U.S. District Judge Katherine Menendez ruled that the federal Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) takes precedence over state law. Her order temporarily blocks the enforcement of the new restrictions against exchanges holding a DCM (Designated Contract Market) license from the CFTC, pending a final ruling on the merits.

Federal Preemption: The Key Argument

Menendez ruled on three related lawsuits simultaneously — against the state of Minnesota, Attorney General Keith Ellison, Governor Tim Walz, and other officials. Kalshi, Polymarket US, and the federal government prevailed on all motions.

Minnesota's law (Minn. Stat. § 609.7615) criminalizes the creation and operation of prediction markets, covering bets on sports, elections, court proceedings, pop culture, and statements by specific individuals. It also penalizes advertising and related services for such markets.

The CFTC filed its lawsuit in May, after Walz signed the law. Commission Chairman Michael Selig stated that the ban would subject weather contracts — used by the state's farmers to hedge against adverse risks — to criminal prosecution. Menendez noted that the CEA grants the CFTC exclusive authority to regulate swap transactions conducted on DCM-licensed platforms. The judge added that both platforms handle numerous transactions — including those related to elections and global politics — which likely fall under the definition of swaps. Consequently, the state of Minnesota likely lacks the authority to regulate them.

"Kalshi and Polymarket US are registered exchanges with DCM status, so only the CFTC can regulate transactions involving the specified swaps," the court ruling states.

Final Ruling: A Temporary but Complete Victory

Menendez emphasized that not every event contract falls under the definition of a swap. For example, Kalshi's markets on the winners of the Love Island USA show and the number of mentions of hosts during the World Cup likely do not fall under the CEA.

As the judge noted, both sides built their arguments on an "all or nothing" basis. In such a situation, the court had little room for a more targeted ruling, so the law's enforcement is suspended entirely.

Concerns about irreparable harm also played a significant role. Kalshi reported over 90,000 verified users from Minnesota as of May 26, with open positions totaling millions of dollars. If the ban had taken effect, state immunity would have prevented the companies from recovering their losses.

The court has not yet addressed the exchanges' First Amendment arguments. This issue, along with the principle of implied federal preemption, will be examined in the final ruling on the merits.

My analysis: This ruling sets a precedent that could halt a wave of similar bans in other states. Prediction markets, especially those focused on political events, are becoming powerful tools for hedging and information gathering. The CFTC appears intent on protecting its jurisdiction, which is good for the industry: uniform federal regulation is preferable to a patchwork of state laws.