A federal court in the United States has dealt a serious blow to the ambitions of the state of Minnesota, which attempted to impose criminal liability for organizing and operating prediction markets. Just days before the law was set to take effect on August 1, Judge Katherine Menendez of the U.S. District Court issued a temporary restraining order blocking its enforcement against exchanges regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). This decision was a triumph for the platforms Kalshi and Polymarket US, as well as for the CFTC itself, which jointly sought the preliminary injunction.

The court's key argument was the supremacy of the federal Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) over state law. Judge Menendez indicated that the CEA grants the CFTC exclusive authority to regulate swap transactions executed on licensed designated contract markets (DCMs). Since both Kalshi and Polymarket US hold DCM status, Minnesota apparently does not have the right to impose its own, stricter restrictions on their activities.

The Minnesota law (Minn. Stat. § 609.7615) was extremely repressive. It criminalized not only the creation of prediction markets for the outcomes of elections, sporting events, and legal proceedings, but also advertising and related services. The CFTC filed a lawsuit against the state back in May, immediately after the law was signed by Governor Tim Walz. Commission Chairman Michael Selig then emphasized that this ban would threaten even legal weather contracts used by the state's farmers to hedge against adverse conditions.

The judge also considered the argument of irreparable harm. Kalshi provided data on over 90,000 verified users in Minnesota and millions of dollars in open positions. State immunity would have deprived the companies of the ability to recover damages if the law had taken effect. The judge noted that both sides built their arguments on an "all-or-nothing" basis, which left the court no room for a more targeted solution, so the law's enforcement is fully suspended pending a final ruling on the merits.

My analysis: This decision is a landmark precedent for the entire prediction market industry in the United States. It clearly demonstrates that states cannot act unilaterally, ignoring the federal regulation of the CFTC. However, the final battle is still ahead. The question of how broadly the term "swap" is interpreted and how the First Amendment protects such markets will be decided when the final verdict is rendered. For now, Kalshi and Polymarket can breathe a sigh of relief, but it's too early to relax — this is only the first round of a protracted legal war.