Federal District Judge Katherine Menendez issued a ruling that temporarily halted the enforcement of a Minnesota state law banning prediction markets. The temporary restraining order was issued just days before August 1, the date the law was set to take effect. Major players such as Kalshi, Polymarket US, and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) itself were affected by this decision.

Federal Law vs. State Law

At the core of the court's decision is the principle of federal supremacy. Judge Menendez ruled that the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) likely takes precedence over local legislation. This means the state of Minnesota cannot apply its restrictions to exchanges that hold a Designated Contract Market (DCM) license and are under CFTC oversight.

The judge noted that numerous transactions occur on such platforms — including those related to elections and global politics — which fall under the definition of "swaps." Consequently, only the federal regulator can oversee them. The ruling emphasizes: "Kalshi and Polymarket US are registered exchanges with DCM status, therefore only the CFTC can regulate transactions involving the specified swaps."

Details of the Law and Arguments from Both Sides

The Minnesota law (Minn. Stat. § 609.7615) introduced criminal penalties for creating and operating prediction markets, including bets on sports, elections, legal proceedings, and pop culture. It also banned advertising and related services for such markets. The CFTC filed a lawsuit back in May, after Governor Tim Walz signed the bill.

Commission Chairman Michael Selig stated that this ban would jeopardize weather contracts used by the state's farmers to hedge against adverse risks. The judge also considered the risk of irreparable harm: Kalshi reported over 90,000 verified users from Minnesota and millions of dollars in open positions. If the ban took effect, the companies would be unable to recover losses due to state immunity.

What's Next?

For now, the ruling is temporary. Judge Menendez emphasized that not every contract falls under the definition of a swap. For example, Kalshi's markets on winners of the Love Island USA show or the number of mentions of hosts during the World Cup likely do not fall under the CEA. A final decision on the merits of the case will be issued later, at which point the issue of the doctrine of implied federal preemption will also be considered.

Expert Opinion: This ruling is an important precedent for the entire prediction market industry. It confirms that federal regulation takes priority and sets a direction for future legal disputes. In the long term, this could strengthen the positions of platforms like Polymarket and Kalshi and stimulate the development of this segment in the U.S. However, investors should monitor the final decision: if the court sides with the state, it could significantly restrict the market.