A federal court in the United States dealt a blow to the ambitions of Minnesota authorities by blocking a new law that effectively criminalized prediction markets. Judge Katherine Menendez's ruling came just days before August 1, the date the law was set to take effect.

The temporary restraining order was issued in favor of three key parties: the platforms Kalshi and Polymarket US, as well as the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). The judge ruled that the federal Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) takes precedence over state law, meaning Minnesota cannot enforce its restrictions on exchanges registered as Designated Contract Markets (DCMs).

Minnesota's law (Minn. Stat. § 609.7615) introduced criminal liability for organizing and operating prediction markets, including bets on sports, elections, legal proceedings, and even pop culture. The ban covered not only trading but also advertising of such services. However, the court found that swap transactions conducted on licensed platforms fall under the exclusive jurisdiction of the CFTC.

Notably, Judge Menendez pointed out that not every event contract qualifies as a swap. For example, Kalshi's markets on the winner of the show "Love Island USA" or on the number of mentions of hosts during the World Cup are likely not regulated by the CEA. However, given that both sides built their arguments on an "all or nothing" basis, the court declined to draw a fine line and blocked the law entirely.

The decisive factor was the threat of irreparable harm. Kalshi reported that as of May 26, it had over 90,000 verified users from Minnesota, with open positions amounting to millions of dollars. If the law had taken effect, state immunity would have prevented the companies from recovering damages.

Cryptalist Analysis: This ruling is a landmark precedent. It confirms that states cannot unilaterally stifle regulated derivatives markets, even if they involve "sensitive" topics like elections. The CFTC has effectively cemented its status as the primary arbiter in this area, which is especially important ahead of the upcoming U.S. presidential elections. However, the final ruling on the merits could be narrower, and prediction markets should not relax — the battle for legality is just beginning.