One of the most fundamental disputes in Bitcoin's history is brewing around the BIP-110 proposal. The initiative, positioned as an anti-spam measure, proposes introducing a series of restrictions on recording extraneous data in the blockchain for one year. However, key industry figures — Michael Saylor, Adam Back, and Samson Mow — have opposed it. Their position is, at first glance, paradoxical: they do not defend spam, but they categorically oppose the method of eradicating it.

Seven Restrictions Against "Junk"

BIP-110, authored by a developer under the pseudonym Dathon Ohm, introduces seven temporary restrictions. These include: a limit on the size of new addresses (up to 34 bytes, with an exception for OP_RETURN up to 83 bytes), a ban on using the unused Taproot annex field, and restrictions on data size in the witness and control block. A key feature is that the restrictions do not apply to coins created before the soft fork activation. They can be spent as usual, which removes the main fear of fund confiscation. The only exceptions are complex multi-signature schemes with delayed execution, whose owners are advised to transfer their funds in advance.

Activation Method: The Sticking Point

The most acute issue is not the restrictions themselves, but the mechanism for their introduction. BIP-110 uses a modified version of BIP 9, which lowers the activation threshold from 95% to 55% of miners over a period. Moreover, after the voluntary phase, a mandatory phase begins, where nodes that have upgraded to BIP-110 start rejecting blocks without a support signal. The proposal does not have a "FAILED" status — even if miners do not support it, node operators can force activation.

This is, in essence, a return to the mechanics of the 2017 UASF (User-Activated Soft Fork), when a minority of nodes managed to push through SegWit. It worked then, but now, according to critics, it creates a dangerous precedent. In his 110-point essay, Michael Saylor called this "iatrogenesis" — harm from the treatment itself. He argues that "Bitcoin doesn't need guardians of purity, it needs guardians of neutrality."

A Hole in the Code and "Crying Luke Dash"

The situation is aggravated by technical problems. Researcher Dathon Pwn, using ChatGPT, discovered a vulnerability in the BIP-110 activation code that could lead to chain divergence. The essence is that a node that upgrades after accepting a block under the old rules might not re-verify it under the new rules, creating a risk of incompatible histories.

An additional blow was struck by Slovak developer Martin Habovštiak. He recorded a 66-kilobyte TIFF file in the blockchain depicting "Crying Luke Dash Jr.," a supporter of BIP-110, bypassing all the proposed restrictions. The transaction does not use OP_RETURN, Taproot, or OP_IF. In doing so, he vividly demonstrated that the "legal cover" for node operators that BIP-110 supposedly provides is an illusion.

Voting and the Future

Support among miners is minimal — less than 2% of blocks over eight months. The largest pools, including Foundry USA, AntPool, and F2Pool, are either silent or opposed. Foundry, however, conducted a vote among its clients, where silence counts as a "no," making a victory for BIP-110 supporters unlikely.

The mandatory phase is expected in early August. Nodes with BIP-110 will start rejecting blocks without bit 4. This will not lead to a complete network split, but it will create a parallel chain with lower hashrate. Eight months of discussion have changed absolutely nothing for ordinary users — fees and balances continue their own lives.

My analysis: BIP-110 is not so much a technical proposal as a political one. It attempts to solve a problem that is, in essence, a feature, not a bug, of Bitcoin. The network is neutral, and attempting to introduce censorship at the protocol level, even temporarily, creates a dangerous precedent. The lesson of 2017 works both ways here: if a minority can push through changes, then in the future, anyone could do the same. The August fork will show how willing the community is to sacrifice neutrality for comfort.