Cameron Winklevoss, co-founder of the cryptocurrency exchange Gemini, has made a bold statement that could be a turning point for many investors. In his view, the era of rampant speculation around artificial intelligence (AI) has definitively ended. As an alternative, he recommends focusing on two proven digital assets: Bitcoin (BTC) and Zcash (ZEC).
This statement comes amid a crash in South Korea's Kospi index, which plummeted by 10.84% on Tuesday. An automatic circuit breaker halted trading for 20 minutes, but it did not save the situation. Shares of giants Samsung Electronics and SK Hynix lost 13.4% and 14.7%, respectively. Japan's Nikkei 225 also failed to hold, losing about 4%, while memory manufacturer Kioxia fell by more than 18%.
The China Factor and the "Closed Loop" Theory
The key catalyst for the crash was news from China. Changxin Memory Technologies (CXMT) from Hefei, a DRAM chip manufacturer, made a stunning debut on the STAR Market in Shanghai, surging by more than 466%. Its market capitalization exceeded 3.3 trillion yuan, making CXMT the most valuable company on mainland exchanges. According to the prospectus, by 2025, CXMT will account for 7.67% of the global DRAM market—fourth place after Samsung, SK Hynix, and Micron.
At the same time, reports emerged that a state-controlled Chinese company had begun producing lithography machines for immersion deep ultraviolet (DUV) printing—the very equipment previously restricted by Western sanctions.
Against this backdrop, Nigel Green, head of the consulting firm deVere Group, proposed a "closed loop" theory in the AI sector. He claims that Nvidia funds OpenAI, which in turn rents cloud capacity from Oracle, and Oracle uses the revenue to buy chips from Nvidia. "The same dollar is counted three times as revenue as it goes around this circle. There is no real demand here. It's just an accounting trick masquerading as a growth story," Green stated.
An analysis of official reports shows that Green's theory is not without merit, though it contains inaccuracies. Oracle's order volume is indeed higher than his figures—$638 billion in outstanding commitments—but more than half of this amount comes from a single buyer. OpenAI's contract with Oracle exceeds $300 billion over five years, and OpenAI's own losses this year could be around $14 billion on revenue of $25 billion.
Why Winklevoss is Betting on Bitcoin and Zcash?
In the current environment, where the AI market shows signs of overheating and competition from China intensifies, Cameron Winklevoss recommends investors move into safe-haven assets. His affinity for Zcash is not new: in the spring, he already urged buying anonymous cryptocurrencies to protect capital, and last summer, the Winklevoss brothers funded an independent audit of the Zcash protocol after a vulnerability was discovered in the Orchard private pool. Over the past year, the ZEC price has risen by about 1,033%, and the project team successfully launched the Ironwood update.
Economist Peter Schiff also sees the current decline as confirmation of his concerns, pointing to a nearly 48% drop in SpaceX shares from their peak. UBS analysts, on the other hand, believe the AI sector is entering a phase of maturity, not destruction, and the emergence of cheap models merely redistributes demand for capacity.
My expert opinion: Winklevoss's advice seems timely but not indisputable. Bitcoin has not yet shown confident growth during stock market declines, casting doubt on its status as a "safe haven." As for Zcash, its explosive growth over the year has already partially priced in future expectations. Nevertheless, amid structural risks in the AI sector, diversification into proven crypto assets is a reasonable step, not just a hypothesis.