Australia's internet safety regulator, eSafety, has initiated legal proceedings against Telegram, accusing the messenger of systematically ignoring demands to remove extremist content. The lawsuit, filed on July 30 in the Federal Court of Australia, provides for a maximum fine of 54.6 million Australian dollars (about $38 million). This is the first case of applying civil sanctions to a major technology platform under the Online Safety Act 2021.
Nature of the Claims: Refusal to Moderate and Protection of Distributors
According to eSafety's statement, Telegram committed six violations of standards for electronic services. The regulator claims that the messenger did not respond to user complaints about public content featuring executions — such videos remained accessible for up to three weeks. Additionally, Telegram did not block distributors, did not identify already known materials, did not prevent their further distribution, did not enshrine corresponding prohibitions in its terms of service, and did not provide reports to complainants.
Special attention is given to recordings of the terrorist attacks at the Christchurch mosques (2019) and the supermarket in Buffalo (2022). According to eSafety, these materials were only removed three months after the tragic events. eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman Grant warned that such content normalizes extremism and facilitates the recruitment of vulnerable populations, citing the Bondi attack and the ASIO intelligence assessment of rising online radicalization.
The regulator also highlighted the scale of the problem: Australians access Telegram about 1.5 million times per month, public groups can unite up to 200,000 participants, and there are no limits on the number of channel subscribers. This creates a favorable environment for the spread of prohibited content.
Telegram's Position: Denial and Appeal
A Telegram representative categorically rejected the allegations, stating an intention to contest them in court. The company emphasized that calls for violence and propaganda of terrorism are unacceptable on the platform and reported that in 2026 it blocked 153,085 illegal communities. However, the conflict with eSafety has been ongoing for years: back in February 2025, the regulator fined Telegram 1 million Australian dollars ($640,000) for a six-month delay in responding to requests regarding countering child and extremist content. The messenger's management called the fine disproportionate and filed an appeal.
Global Context: Pressure on Telegram Intensifies
This lawsuit is part of a global trend. On July 29, Russia's FSB charged Telegram founder Pavel Durov with aiding terrorism, claiming that the service's administration refused to remove channels and bots used to prepare terrorist attacks. There is no data on Durov's wanted status in the Interpol database yet, but the Lefortovo Court is preparing for his arrest in absentia. In France, the investigation against Durov has been ongoing since August 2024, and in India, in June, authorities restricted access to the messenger and forced its removal from Google and Apple stores due to the spread of leaked exam papers.
Durov, released on bail of €5 million in August 2024, called his arrest in France a "legal absurdity." However, the growing number of lawsuits and investigations indicates that regulators worldwide are losing patience, considering Telegram's moderation model insufficient to combat serious threats.
My Expert Analysis: This lawsuit is a signal for the entire industry. Telegram, positioning itself as a privacy advocate, faces increasing pressure due to its inability to balance free speech and safety. The $38 million fine is just the tip of the iceberg: if the court finds the violations systemic, it could lead to mandatory changes in moderation algorithms, striking at the platform's decentralized management model. For investors and users, this means the era of Telegram's unchecked growth is coming to an end.