The European Union's Markets in Crypto-Assets (MiCA) regulation, conceived as the world's first comprehensive law for digital assets, has in practice turned into a bureaucratic nightmare. Instead of creating a unified and transparent market for 27 countries, it has spawned a fragmented system where less than 8% of crypto companies managed to obtain the necessary licenses by the time the law came into effect.
The MiCA implementation process, which stretched over three years, proved to be overloaded and inconsistent. The key problem is fragmented national approaches to regulation. Instead of harmonization, each country set its own transitional period deadlines: from 5 months in Lithuania to 18 in the Czech Republic. This led to the fact that by mid-2026, only about 17% of companies operating before MiCA had obtained CASP authorization. In effect, approximately 90% of the market found itself outside the legal framework. Five countries — Greece, Hungary, Poland, Portugal, and Romania — did not issue a single license.
Polish paralysis and Binance in a dead end
The situation was particularly acute in Poland, where a political crisis blocked the national licensing system. The president vetoed the MiCA implementation law three times, fearing "excessive powers" for the regulator. As a result, about 2,000 local virtual asset providers were left in limbo, forced to obtain permits in neighboring jurisdictions, which brings additional costs for businesses and a loss of tax revenue for the state.
The world's largest exchange, Binance, also faced a bureaucratic dead end. After submitting an application in Greece, the company encountered non-public ESMA recommendations to reject it due to concerns about anti-money laundering. Ultimately, a week before the deadline, Binance withdrew its application, and from July 1, it restricted services for EU users. This is a stark example of how even resources and size do not guarantee success under opaque and inconsistent regulation.
Farewell to Tether and the triumph of Circle
The largest stablecoin, USDT, has completely lost access to regulated EU exchanges. Tether deliberately refused a MiCA license, considering the requirement to hold 60% of reserves in European banks incompatible with its model of backing by US Treasury bonds. This decision opened the door for its main competitor — Circle with USDC and EURC, which obtained a license in France and became the dominant stablecoin on European platforms.
Regulators, recognizing the failure, have already launched a process to revise MiCA (MiCA 2.0). ESMA has begun public consultations, asking whether administrative barriers can be simplified or even abolished entirely. At the same time, transferring oversight of CASPs from national authorities directly to ESMA is being discussed. However, the current architecture has already caused damage: it has driven companies away, undermined investor confidence, and created a precedent where the "gold standard" of regulation turned into chaos.
My view: MiCA has become a classic example of how good intentions to create unified regulation are shattered by national interests and bureaucratic inertia. Revising the regulation is not just an opportunity to correct mistakes, but a vital measure to preserve the competitiveness of the European crypto market. If Brussels cannot adapt quickly, it risks losing not only companies but the entire technological potential of the region.