The Markets in Crypto-Assets (MiCA) regulation was conceived as a revolution—the world's first comprehensive law uniting 27 EU jurisdictions into a single regulatory space for digital assets. However, reality has proven far more mundane: instead of an orderly system, we are witnessing a deep institutional crisis that has threatened the existence of a significant portion of the European crypto market.
My analysis shows that by the time the rules fully came into force, only about 8% of crypto companies operating in Europe had managed to obtain the necessary licenses. This is not merely a statistical anomaly—it is a systemic failure caused by regulator overload, political conflicts, and internal contradictions within the document itself.
Timeline of failure
MiCA was introduced in stages over three years. First, in June 2023, it became Regulation 2023/1114; then in June 2024, rules for stablecoins came into effect, followed by the main regime for service providers (CASP) on December 30, 2024. Theoretically, applications were to be reviewed within about three months, but in practice, timelines stretched to a year. By May 2026, only 17% of companies operating before MiCA had received authorization, and by July, ESMA's register listed just over 300 licenses—despite more than 3,000 crypto firms operating in the EU before the law was introduced.
A particularly alarming situation has emerged in individual countries. Greece, Hungary, Poland, Portugal, and Romania have not issued a single authorization. Meanwhile, Germany processed 23% of all applications, which only underscores the imbalance. Varying transitional periods—from five months in Lithuania to 18 in the Czech Republic and France—have completely shattered the illusion of a single market.
Polish deadlock and Binance's exit
The most telling example of chaos is Poland, where President Karol Nawrocki vetoed the implementation of MiCA three times, blocking the issuance of licenses for approximately 2,000 local providers. Companies are forced to move to Lithuania or Germany, leading to lost tax revenue and an outflow of startups.
No less dramatic is the situation with Binance. The largest exchange filed an application in Greece in January 2026 but faced non-public ESMA recommendations to reject documents due to anti-money laundering concerns. Ultimately, the company withdrew its application itself a week before the deadline, limiting services for European clients. This is a signal: even giants with vast resources cannot navigate the process when regulators act inconsistently.
Tether's exodus and Circle's victory
A separate story is Tether's voluntary exit from the European market. The requirement to hold 60% of reserves in European banks is incompatible with the issuer's business model, which is based on U.S. Treasury bonds. As I have noted in my previous analyses, this created a vacuum that Circle immediately filled with USDC and EURC, having secured a license in France. The EU stablecoin market is now effectively monopolized by a single player—which hardly aligns with the spirit of competition embedded in MiCA.
Attempts at correction
Regulators are aware of the scale of the problem. ESMA has launched public consultations on revising MiCA (the so-called MiCA 2.0), and in July began a coordinated review of custodial risks. In Brussels, there is discussion of transferring oversight of CASPs directly to ESMA, although experts call this "legally dubious." Meanwhile, supervision is tightening over those who have managed to obtain licenses.
My expert opinion: MiCA demonstrates the classic problem of "regulatory overload," where the ambitious goal of creating a single market crashes against the bureaucratic reality of national interests. Until the EU resolves the issue of fragmentation and inconsistent enforcement, Europe risks not only scaring off investors but also losing its status as a global crypto hub. Revising the regime is an opportunity, but it requires officials to have the courage to admit their own mistakes rather than shifting blame onto the market.