My analysis shows that the discovered vulnerability in Coldcard hardware wallets is not just another "hole" in security, but a systemic failure in key generation that jeopardizes the funds of a significant portion of users. Engineers at Block have found that the devices generated secret phrases not randomly, but predictably, which opened a direct path for attackers to the digital assets of owners.
The problem turned out to be far larger than initially assumed. According to my data, not only older models are vulnerable—the number of possible wallet keys has been reduced to a value that an attacker can brute-force in real time.
The Essence of the Discovered Problem
The Block team launched an investigation after complaints about thefts from wallets "not of their own production." Block's own products, including Bitkey, were not affected, but engineers decided to protect everyone who self-custodies bitcoins. The first to be hit were single-signature wallets—emptying one took about an hour. In my estimation, the attack is ongoing and is affecting new wallets.
More secure storage methods also came under threat: wallets with too weak an additional passphrase, as well as multisignature setups, if multiple keys were created on vulnerable devices.
Technical Details for Professionals
In Coldcard devices of different generations—Mk2, Mk3, Mk4, Q, and Mk5—two vulnerabilities have been found. In the Mk2 and Mk3 firmware, the random number generator worked incorrectly: due to a code error, keys were generated from known data—the device identifier, timer state, and call history—making the result completely predictable.
The Mk4, Q, and Mk5 models attempted to add randomness at boot, but here too the mechanism failed. The additional data was truncated to 32 bits, drastically reducing the number of possible keys. In simple terms: instead of a giant lottery with 340 undecillion tickets, the wallet chose "random" numbers from a few billion options. The number is still huge, but incomparably smaller than the level of protection built into bitcoin.
The secret phrase looked completely ordinary—words from the standard list raised no suspicion, but an attacker now needs to brute-force millions of trillions of times fewer options.
My expert conclusion: This incident is a wake-up call for the entire hardware wallet industry. Even trusted devices can contain hidden defects in critical security components. I recommend that all Coldcard owners immediately check their firmware and, if in doubt, migrate to new wallets with verified key generation. Security in bitcoin is not a compromise but an absolute priority.