Australia's online safety regulator (eSafety) has initiated a civil lawsuit against Telegram in the Federal Court, accusing the platform of systematically failing to remove content related to terrorism propaganda. The case concerns videos that remained publicly accessible for weeks despite direct notifications from users.
The essence of eSafety's claims
The proceedings are the result of a year-long investigation. The regulator alleges that Telegram failed to remove recordings linked to the Christchurch mosque tragedies (2019) and the mass shooting in Buffalo (2022). According to eSafety, this material remained publicly accessible for up to three months after complaints were received. Moreover, the platform allegedly failed to inform users of the outcomes of their complaints.
Commissioner Julie Inman Grant emphasized: "This is about content linked to the most high-profile acts of extremist violence in recent years. We allege that it remained accessible even after Telegram was notified." The maximum fine in this case could reach 54.6 million Australian dollars (about $38 million).
Telegram's position
In response to the allegations, representatives of the messenger stated their complete disagreement and readiness to defend themselves in court. They insist that their counter-terrorism policy is clearly documented and enforced. The statistics are striking: in Australia alone, Telegram is used about 1.5 million times monthly, while the platform's global audience exceeds 1 billion users.
This lawsuit is just part of the growing legal pressure on the messenger. Earlier, Russia made claims against founder Pavel Durov, and in August 2024 he was detained in France, after which he left the country and moved to Dubai.
My analysis: The situation shows that regulators worldwide are tightening requirements for content moderation, and Telegram, which has long positioned itself as a bastion of free speech, finds itself caught between a rock and a hard place. For the crypto community, this is an important signal: legal risks for technology platforms are growing, and investors should consider this when assessing the long-term prospects of such projects. If the court rules in favor of eSafety, it will create a precedent that could impact the entire decentralized communications industry.