Australia's online safety regulator (eSafety) has officially initiated a civil lawsuit against Telegram in the Federal Court. The reason — the messenger's systematic inaction in identifying and removing materials that promote terrorism. This concerns video recordings that remained publicly accessible despite direct user complaints.
This case is the result of a year-long investigation that revealed gross violations of local safety standards. If the platform's guilt is proven, the company faces a fine of up to 54.6 million Australian dollars, equivalent to approximately $38 million. The figure is significant, but for Telegram with its multi-billion audience, this is more a matter of principle than a financial catastrophe.
What exactly is the platform being accused of
According to eSafety, Telegram not only ignored signals but deliberately allowed the posting of prohibited content. In particular, this concerns recordings of the shootings at mosques in Christchurch in 2019 and the mass shooting in Buffalo in 2022. These videos, according to the regulator, remained available on the platform for almost three months after users reported them.
Moreover, eSafety claims that Telegram's rules banning the promotion of terrorism did not apply to all sections of the app, and the platform itself did not inform complainants about the results of reviewing their reports. Commissioner Julie Inman Grant emphasizes: content related to the most high-profile terrorist attacks of recent years remained publicly accessible even after Telegram was officially notified of its existence.
Telegram's position and the context of pressure
In response to the accusations, Telegram categorically rejects the claims, stating that their efforts to combat terrorism are well documented, and they are ready to contest the lawsuit in court. However, this is only part of a broader picture. Pressure on the messenger is growing worldwide: Russia has already brought charges against founder Pavel Durov for facilitating terrorist activity, and in August 2024 he was detained in France.
Durov himself links these attacks to Telegram's refusal to comply with demands for mass surveillance and censorship. In 2025, he left France and moved to Dubai. Significantly, the Australian lawsuit was filed at a time when the messenger, with over 1 billion users worldwide, including 1.5 million active in Australia, is under close scrutiny from regulators.
My analysis: This is a landmark case. If eSafety wins, it will create a dangerous template for other jurisdictions demanding active moderation from decentralized platforms. The question is not whether Telegram removed specific videos, but how far regulators can go in their demands regarding privacy architecture. For the crypto community, which values anonymity and freedom, this is an alarming signal: the fight for privacy is becoming increasingly expensive.