Australia's online safety regulator (eSafety) has filed a civil lawsuit against Telegram in the Federal Court. The reason is the platform's systematic failure to meet its obligations to identify and remove content promoting terrorism, including video recordings that remained accessible to users for extended periods.

The Core of the Complaints: From Christchurch to Buffalo

My analysis shows that the case involves egregious examples. It concerns recordings of the shootings at mosques in Christchurch (2019) and the mass shooting in Buffalo (2022). According to the regulator, these materials remained publicly accessible on the platform for nearly three months after receiving complaints from users. Moreover, eSafety claims that Telegram's rules prohibited the promotion of terrorism only in certain sections of the app, not across the entire platform, and that the administration did not inform users of the results of reviewing their appeals.

"We allege that this content remained accessible even after Telegram was notified," said eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman Grant.

Scale of Pressure and Telegram's Position

The regulator initiated the proceedings after a year-long investigation. The maximum fine could reach 54.6 million Australian dollars (about $38 million). Notably, the messenger's audience in Australia is about 1.5 million monthly active uses, while its global base exceeds 1 billion users.

Telegram categorically rejects the allegations. In an official statement, the company emphasizes that its efforts to combat terrorism are well-documented and intends to contest the lawsuit in court. "We reject these allegations and will contest them in court," a platform representative said.

Growing Crisis of Trust

This lawsuit is only part of the global legal pressure on the messenger. Earlier, Russia brought charges against founder Pavel Durov for facilitating terrorist activity, and in August 2024, he was detained in France, after which he was released on bail. Later, Durov left the country and moved to Dubai.

My verdict: The situation for Telegram is becoming critical. Regulators worldwide are increasingly scrutinizing messengers for content moderation, and Australia is likely to set a precedent for other jurisdictions. If eSafety wins the case, it will create a dangerous legal canon for the platform that could impact the entire decentralized communications industry.