My analysis of Bank of Italy data leads to an unexpected conclusion: stablecoins, often positioned as a revolution in cross-border payments, do not demonstrate a systematic superiority over classic bank transfers. This is an important signal for a market accustomed to believing in the technological superiority of digital assets.
As part of a large-scale study, 200 test transactions in USDC were conducted from Italy to Brazil, Argentina, Japan, the UAE, and South Africa. The results were mixed: transfer fees ranged from a modest 0.3% to nearly 9% depending on the destination. The key factor determining efficiency was not the blockchain technology itself, but the quality of the local payment infrastructure.
In countries with developed instant payment systems, fund delivery took less than 20 minutes. However, where such infrastructure is absent, waiting times stretched to 1-2 business days—completely negating the advantage of decentralized assets. In my view, the bottleneck remains the conversion of stablecoins into fiat currencies, which requires the involvement of traditional financial intermediaries and creates additional delays and costs.
This study undermines the narrative that stablecoins automatically solve the problem of slow and expensive international transfers. In reality, the efficiency of such operations depends on how well digital assets are integrated into the existing financial ecosystem. As long as this integration leaves much to be desired, talk of a complete replacement of traditional systems is premature.
My comment: The Bank of Italy data confirms my long-standing position: stablecoins are not a panacea, but a tool that merely reflects the state of the financial system into which it is embedded. Investors and users should consider that the real value of such assets will only be revealed after a large-scale modernization of payment infrastructure worldwide.