The Regional Court of Munich has issued a ruling that could become a turning point for the entire generative music industry. The lawsuit filed by the German rights management society GEMA against the startup Suno has been upheld: the court found that the company used six copyright-protected compositions from GEMA's catalog without the appropriate license to train its AI models and subsequently generate tracks.
These include iconic works such as Daddy Cool and Rasputin by Boney M., Forever Young by Alphaville, and Mambo No. 5 by Lou Bega. For me, this is a particularly telling selection—it spans different eras and genres, highlighting the systemic nature of the violation rather than an isolated incident.
Positions of the parties and prospects
Suno strongly disagrees with the ruling and has already announced its intention to appeal. This is expected: the stakes are high for the company, as this case sets a dangerous precedent for an entire business model based on the mass use of musical data without transparent licensing agreements.
Notably, this is not GEMA's first victory in such disputes. Earlier this year, the organization won a similar case against OpenAI related to the reproduction of song lyrics in ChatGPT. This points to the formation of consistent case law in Germany, where collective rights management operates particularly strictly.
In my view, this ruling is just the tip of the iceberg. It creates a legal foundation for dozens of similar lawsuits from other rights holders and increases pressure on AI music platforms worldwide. The industry will have to urgently rethink its approaches to licensing training data; otherwise, legal costs could prove more fatal than any technical limitations.