The Regional Court of Munich has issued a verdict that could set a benchmark for the entire generative AI industry. The lawsuit filed by the German rights management society GEMA against the music startup Suno was upheld in full. The court ruled that the company used six tracks from GEMA's catalog without a corresponding licensing agreement to train its models and subsequently generate music. The list includes iconic compositions — Daddy Cool, Rasputin, Forever Young, and Mambo No. 5.

The Essence of the Claims and the Positions of the Parties

The key aspect of the case is not the act of generation itself, but the use of protected works as training data. GEMA insists that this is a direct violation of copyright, requiring compensation. Suno, for its part, has already stated its disagreement with the decision and is preparing an appeal. The startup will likely cite the doctrine of fair use, but in the German jurisdiction, this argument traditionally faces stiff resistance, especially when commercial gain is involved.

Precedent Context

This is not GEMA's first victory in such disputes. Earlier this year, the organization won a similar case against OpenAI related to the reproduction of song lyrics in ChatGPT. Thus, the German court is consistently shaping a legal position: the use of content for AI without the explicit permission of the rights holder is unacceptable, even if the result is transformed.

My view: This decision increases pressure on all AI platforms working with musical content. I expect that after Suno's appeal, the market will see a wave of licensing agreements with collective societies — this is the inevitable price for legalizing generative models in Europe. Investors should take into account the increased regulatory risks when evaluating such startups.