The Munich Regional Court has issued a landmark ruling that could reshape the rules of the game for the entire generative AI industry. The lawsuit filed by the German rights management society GEMA against the startup Suno has been upheld in full. The court found that the company used six tracks from GEMA's catalog to train its models and generate music without the appropriate license. These include iconic compositions such as Daddy Cool, Rasputin, Forever Young, and Mambo No. 5.

This is not merely a technical dispute over compliance with formalities. The court's decision highlights a fundamental problem: AI developers often ignore copyright, believing that training on others' works is "fair use" or something similar. But European jurisdiction, especially German, demonstrates a strict approach. GEMA already won a similar case against OpenAI this year, when ChatGPT reproduced song lyrics without permission. Now it is the turn of music generators.

Suno, of course, disagrees with the verdict. The company has already announced its intention to appeal. Predictably: for the startup, this is a matter of survival, because if the ruling stands, it will have to either completely overhaul its model training process or negotiate costly licenses with rights holders worldwide.

My view as an analyst

This case is just the tip of the iceberg. We are witnessing a systemic shift: courts are beginning to close the "gray area" in the use of data for AI. For investors in the crypto and tech sectors, this is a signal: projects relying on unlicensed content carry enormous legal risks. Those who build transparent relationships with rights holders in advance will gain a competitive advantage. Suno is not the last company to face such lawsuits, and this should be taken into account when assessing the prospects of the entire generative AI field.