My analysis of a study conducted by the Bank of Italy revealed an unexpected aspect: stablecoins, despite their reputation as a fast and cheap tool, do not demonstrate a sustained advantage in international money transfers. The experiment, covering $200 USDC transfers across ten bilateral corridors between Italy and countries such as Brazil, Argentina, Japan, the UAE, and South Africa, showed that key benefits are offset at the stages of conversion into fiat currencies and interaction with local payment systems.

Real numbers and hidden costs

The final cost of stablecoin transfers ranged from 0.3% to nearly 9% depending on the transfer direction. This is a critical point: in corridors where instant payment systems operated, settlements took less than 20 minutes. However, where such infrastructure was absent, timelines stretched to one or two business days—completely negating the blockchain advantage. The main drivers of costs and delays were currency exchange and the quality of local infrastructure, not network gas fees.

Comparison with traditional services

The global average cost of transfers, according to my data, is about 6.65%. In most of the corridors studied, stablecoins were indeed cheaper than this level. However, in a direct comparison with Wise, a leader in digital transfers, stablecoins won in only three out of seven comparable corridors. This suggests that existing fintech solutions have already achieved high efficiency, and stablecoins do not offer the revolutionary leap many expected.

The study's authors rightly note: the real potential of stablecoins will only be unlocked when they can be spent directly on goods and services, bypassing the reverse conversion into local currency. Furthermore, prohibitive regulatory measures do not reduce demand for "stable coins" but merely complicate their use for retail clients.

Against the backdrop of these findings, I recall that in July, the total market capitalization of stablecoins shrank by more than $10 billion from the May peak, dropping to ~$310 billion. This is the largest monthly decline since the collapse of Terra in May 2022—a signal that the market is reassessing its expectations for this asset class.

My expert opinion: This study confirms that stablecoins are not a universal solution but a tool with niche efficiency. Their future depends not on technology but on integration with the real economy and regulatory clarity. Until these conditions are met, traditional payment systems remain worthy competitors.