My analysis of a new study by the Bank of Italy shows that the hype around stablecoins as a panacea for cross-border transfers does not hold up to scrutiny. The central bank conducted a large-scale test, comparing $200 USDC transfers across ten bilateral corridors between Italy and countries such as Brazil, Argentina, Japan, the UAE, and South Africa. The results were sobering.
Numbers that break stereotypes
The total cost of stablecoin transactions ranged from a modest 0.3% to a shocking 9%, depending on the corridor. The key takeaway: all the advantages of blockchain are negated at the stage of converting to fiat and integrating with local payment systems. In corridors with developed instant payment infrastructure, settlements took less than 20 minutes, but where such systems are absent, timelines stretched to one or two business days—exactly like traditional banks.
The key costs are not related to blockchain fees, as many assume, but to exchange operations and the quality of local payment networks. For comparison: the global average cost of transfers, according to World Bank data, is 6.65%. In most of the corridors studied, stablecoins did prove cheaper than this level, but in a direct comparison with Wise, an advantage was recorded in only three of seven comparable corridors.
Hidden potential and regulatory paradoxes
The study's authors rightly note that the real impact of stablecoins will only materialize when they can be spent directly on goods and services, without converting back into local currency. For now, we are only witnessing an intermediate stage of evolution.
Particular attention deserves the conclusion on regulation: prohibitive measures do not eliminate demand for "stable coins," but merely complicate their use for retail clients. At the same time, let me remind you that in July, the market capitalization of stablecoins fell by more than $10 billion from its May peak, to ~$310 billion, marking the largest monthly outflow since the collapse of Terra in 2022.
My verdict: stablecoins are not yet a revolution in money transfers, but rather a niche tool. Their future depends not on technology, but on the industry's ability to create seamless bridges with traditional finance. Until then, investors and users should soberly assess real costs rather than marketing promises.