The Russian judicial system has taken an important step in defining the legal status of generative art. A Moscow court refused to recognize authorship for images created by artificial intelligence algorithms, rejecting a claim for compensation for rights infringement. This decision is the first significant attempt to answer the question that concerns the entire creative community: can a machine be considered a creator?
At the center of the dispute were modified versions of classical works — "Mona Lisa with Wine" and "Statue of Liberty with Wine." The entrepreneur who acted as the plaintiff used a generative neural network to process the original digital images. First, he purchased the originals, then gave the algorithm a command to replace the Statue of Liberty's torch with a wine glass and update the background landscape. In the case of the Mona Lisa, the program made more subtle edits: it changed the contours of the face, added bags under the eyes, made the hairstyle more disheveled, and "placed" a glass of wine in the hand with painted nails.
The businessman applied the finished art objects to T-shirts, hoodies, sweatshirts, and thermal mugs, selling the products through an online store. However, the defendant categorically refused to acknowledge the claims, insisting on the absence of copyright for "insignificant edits."
Why the court refused protection
The key argument of the judges was the nature of the process itself. The neural network, as emphasized by the court, does not possess consciousness, and therefore there can be no talk of the program's creative contribution. The plaintiff's selection of commands was characterized as "simple mechanical manipulations," not as an act of creation.
The court paid special attention to the secondary nature of the ideas themselves. In the world history of art, disheveled hair, puffy faces, glasses of wine in the hands of famous characters, and the replacement of a torch with household objects have already been encountered many times. Transferring others' concepts onto old canvases through queries to a program was not recognized as creativity.
Legal uncertainty persists
This decision reflects the general ambiguity surrounding the status of generative content in Russia. Current legislation still does not provide a clear answer about who owns the rights to works created with the help of AI. Judicial practice is being formed only through isolated cases, which creates ground for further disputes.
It is indicative that the State Duma is already discussing initiatives to introduce criminal liability for crimes involving neural networks. However, the question of protecting copyright for "machine" creativity remains open. For now, courts lean toward a conservative approach, but with the development of technology, this position will inevitably be reconsidered — the economic and cultural stakes in this field are too high.
My view: This verdict is only a temporary point in a long discussion. On the one hand, it protects the classical understanding of creative labor. On the other hand, it ignores the reality where a person acts as a curator and co-author, setting the direction for the algorithm. The question is not whether a machine can create, but how we evaluate the role of a person in this process. Until legislation catches up with technology, such disputes will only multiply.