A Moscow court has issued a landmark ruling that could redefine the legal status of images created by artificial intelligence algorithms. The court refused to recognize such art objects as the result of human creative activity, which automatically deprived their author of the right to compensation for copyright infringement. This is the first high-profile precedent of its kind in Russian jurisdiction, and its significance for the generative content industry cannot be overstated.
The essence of the conflict: from the "Mona Lisa" to the "Statue of Liberty"
The dispute erupted over a series of modified classical works — "Mona Lisa with Wine" and "Statue of Liberty with Wine." The plaintiff, an entrepreneur, purchased the original digital images and then modified them using a generative neural network: he replaced the Statue of Liberty's torch with a glass of wine and changed the background landscape. For the "Mona Lisa," the algorithm made more subtle edits — adjusted facial contours, added bags under the eyes, increased hair volume, and placed a glass in the heroine's hand.
The businessman applied the finished artworks to T-shirts, sweatshirts, hoodies, and thermal mugs, selling the products through an online store. When the defendant, who printed these designs, refused to acknowledge the claims, the case went to court. The plaintiff demanded compensation, insisting on his authorship, but the defense countered: the "minor edits" lack a creative component.
Why the court refused: lack of consciousness and secondary nature of ideas
The court's key argument was the absence of consciousness in the computer algorithm. The judges emphasized that one cannot speak of a program's creative contribution, and the plaintiff's actions in selecting commands were merely "simple mechanical manipulations." Additionally, the court pointed to the secondary nature of the ideas themselves: disheveled hair, a glass in the hands of famous characters, and replacing a torch with household objects — all of this has appeared repeatedly in art before.
The court did not consider transferring others' concepts onto old canvases through neural network prompts to be creativity. This ruling reflects the general uncertainty in the legal field: current Russian legislation still does not regulate copyright when using AI. Judicial practice is being formed piecemeal, through isolated cases, while the State Duma is already discussing the possibility of introducing criminal liability for crimes involving neural networks.
My comment: This verdict is just the tip of the iceberg. For the crypto and NFT industry, where generative artworks are actively tokenized, the lack of a clear legal status creates serious risks. Until legislators determine who exactly is the author — a human, an algorithm, or a joint product — investors and digital art creators remain in a zone of legal turbulence. The market needs clear rules, otherwise courts will continue to make contradictory decisions, hindering the development of legal AI art.