A Moscow court has issued a landmark ruling that could set a precedent for all Russian law enforcement practice in the field of artificial intelligence. The court refused to recognize images generated by neural networks as creative works and, consequently, rejected the author's lawsuit seeking compensation for copyright infringement. The dispute centered around the art objects "Mona Lisa with Wine" and "Statue of Liberty with Wine," which the defendant printed on clothing and tableware.
Details of the conflict and the plaintiff's position
The plaintiff, an entrepreneur, purchased the original digital images and then modified them using a generative neural network. In the case of the "Mona Lisa," the algorithm made significant changes: it adjusted the facial contours, made the hairstyle more disheveled, and "added" a glass of wine to the hand with painted nails. For the "Statue of Liberty," the program, upon command, replaced the torch with a wine glass and updated the background landscape. The businessman applied the finished images to T-shirts, hoodies, sweatshirts, and thermal mugs, selling the products through an online store. The defendant, in turn, categorically rejected the claims, insisting on the absence of copyright for the generated images.
Why the court refused protection
The court's key argument was the lack of consciousness in the computer algorithm. According to the judges, there can be no talk of a creative contribution by the program, and the plaintiff's actions in selecting commands were merely simple mechanical manipulations. The judges also emphasized the derivative nature of the ideas themselves: disheveled hair, puffy faces, a glass of wine in the hands of famous characters, and replacing a torch with a household item—all of this has appeared repeatedly in art. The court did not consider transferring others' ideas onto old works through program queries to be creativity.
This ruling reflects the general uncertainty surrounding the status of generative content in Russia. Current legislation does not yet regulate copyright when using AI, so judicial practice is built from isolated cases. Notably, the State Duma is already discussing the introduction of criminal liability for crimes involving neural networks.
My comment: This ruling is merely the tip of the iceberg. Until the legislator provides a clear definition of "creative participation" by a human in the generation process, we will see contradictory verdicts. For the digital art and NFT market, this creates significant legal risks that must be taken into account now.