A Moscow court has set an important precedent in the debate over the legal status of images created by neural networks. The court refused to recognize such works as the result of creative labor, which automatically deprived the author of the right to compensation for infringement of their rights. This is the first such unequivocal ruling in Russian practice, and it sets the direction for future disputes.
The Essence of the Conflict
At the center of the dispute were modified versions of classic works — "Mona Lisa with Wine" and "Statue of Liberty with Wine." The plaintiff, an entrepreneur, purchased the original digital images and then used a generative neural network to transform them: the algorithm replaced the Statue of Liberty's torch with a glass of wine, and in the case of the Mona Lisa, adjusted facial features, hairstyle, and added a vessel with a drink to her hand. The businessman applied the resulting works to T-shirts, sweatshirts, and thermal mugs, selling them through an online store.
The defendant, who printed these designs on clothing and dishware, categorically rejected the claims. Their defense was based on the argument that the plaintiff holds no copyright to such "derivative" objects, and the generation process itself does not constitute creativity.
Why the Court Refused
The court's key argument was the lack of consciousness in a computer algorithm. The judges emphasized that one cannot speak of a program's creative contribution, and the plaintiff's actions in selecting commands were merely "simple mechanical manipulations." Moreover, the court noted the derivative nature of the ideas themselves: disheveled hair, a glass of wine in the hands of famous characters, and replacing a torch with an everyday object — all of this has already appeared repeatedly in art. Transferring others' concepts onto old canvases through program prompts was not recognized as a creative act.
Legal Uncertainty
This ruling reflects the general confusion surrounding the status of generative content in Russia. Current legislation does not regulate copyright when using AI, so judicial practice is being shaped piecemeal, through individual cases. Meanwhile, the State Duma is already discussing the introduction of criminal liability for crimes involving neural networks.
My analysis: This case is a signal for all participants in the digital art and NFT market. The court effectively equated image generation to a technical operation rather than a creative act. Until clear legislation emerges, authors using AI remain in a legal gray zone: their works may not receive protection, and the commercial use of such objects may be challenged. Investors and content creators should consider this risk when evaluating assets related to generative art.