A Moscow court has issued a landmark ruling that could serve as a starting point for the entire legal practice in the field of generative art. The court refused to recognize copyright for images created by neural networks, thereby putting a definitive end to a question that had until now sparked fierce disputes within the professional community.

At the center of the conflict were modified versions of classic works — "Mona Lisa with Wine" and "Statue of Liberty with Wine." The entrepreneur, acting as the plaintiff, purchased the original digital images and then, using a generative model, commanded it to replace the Statue of Liberty's torch with a wine glass. The neural network also made adjustments to the background landscape. In the case of the Mona Lisa, the algorithm altered the contours of the face, added bags under the eyes, made the hairstyle more disheveled, and "placed" a wine glass in a hand with painted nails.

The businessman applied the finished art objects to T-shirts, hoodies, sweatshirts, and thermal mugs, selling the products through an online store. However, the defendant categorically refused to acknowledge the claim, insisting that the creator of such "derivative" works had no copyright.

Why the court did not see creativity

The key argument of the judges was the absence of consciousness in the computer algorithm. According to the court, it is impossible to speak of a program's creative contribution, and the plaintiff's actions in selecting commands were deemed simple mechanical manipulations. The court also noted the derivative nature of the ideas themselves: disheveled hair, puffy faces, a wine glass in the hands of famous characters, and replacing a torch with everyday objects — all of this has appeared repeatedly in art before. Transferring others' concepts onto old works through queries to a program was not recognized as creativity.

This ruling reflects the general uncertainty surrounding the status of generative content in Russia. Current legislation does not yet regulate copyright when using AI, and judicial practice is being shaped by isolated cases. Notably, the State Duma is already discussing the possibility of introducing criminal liability for crimes involving neural networks.

My analysis: This verdict is merely the first stone in the foundation of future regulation. The generative art market in Russia exists in a legal vacuum, and such rulings will create precedents that could either slow the development of creative industries or protect the interests of classic authors. In any case, businesses working with AI content should calculate legal risks in advance, since current practice is clearly not on the side of "digital creators."