A Moscow court has issued a landmark ruling that sets the direction for the entire generative content industry in Russia. Images created by neural networks are not recognized as the result of human creative activity, and therefore do not fall under copyright protection. The claim for compensation for rights infringement was denied — and this is the first such unequivocal precedent in the domestic jurisdiction.

The essence of the dispute: from "Mona Lisa" to "Statue of Liberty"

At the center of the conflict were art objects created based on classical works but reworked by an algorithm. The case concerns images of "Mona Lisa with Wine" and "Statue of Liberty with Wine." An entrepreneur purchased the original digital files and then modified them using a generative neural network: he replaced the statue's torch with a glass, updated the background, and detailed the facial features.

The finished works were applied to T-shirts, hoodies, sweatshirts, and thermal mugs, which were sold through an online store. The defendant — the product manufacturer — categorically rejected the plaintiff's claims, stating that he had no exclusive rights to such images.

Why the court saw no creativity

The court's key argument is the lack of consciousness in a computer algorithm. According to the court, selecting commands and parameters for a neural network is mechanical manipulation, not a creative act. The program operates based on statistical patterns, not inspiration, so its "contribution" to the work cannot be recognized as authorship.

The judges also pointed to the derivative nature of the ideas: disheveled hair, a glass in the character's hand, or replacing a torch with a household item — all of this has long appeared in art. Transferring others' concepts onto old canvases through program prompts does not create a new work in the legal sense.

Legal uncertainty and the future of AI content

This ruling reflects the general confusion surrounding the status of generative content in Russian legislation. Current norms do not regulate copyright when using AI, so courts are forced to act on a precedent basis. The State Duma is already discussing the possibility of introducing criminal liability for crimes involving neural networks, but the question of the creative status of machine-generated images remains open.

My comment: For the market, this is a signal: until the legislator makes a decision, businesses using AI generation are in a risk zone. Investors and content creators should build legal structures in advance that secure rights to such assets — otherwise, courts will interpret them in favor of "human" authorship or outright deny protection, as happened here.