The failure of the CLARITY Act in the U.S. Congress marks not a slowdown, but rather an acceleration of the crypto regulation process. Instead of waiting for a single legislative act, key American regulators — the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) — will now be forced to act independently, which, in my assessment, will lead to more fragmented but expedited rulemaking.

Bernstein analysts emphasize that the absence of the CLARITY Act leaves regulators no choice but to fill the legal vacuum with their own initiatives. This means that in the coming months, we will see a series of clarifications and directives addressing fundamental industry issues. First and foremost, this concerns the classification of tokens — whether they will be recognized as securities or commodities, which will determine the jurisdiction of the SEC or CFTC, respectively.

Additionally, clarifications are expected regarding the regulation of decentralized finance (DeFi), where there remains significant uncertainty about the liability of protocols and their creators. Self-custody issues will also come to the forefront, as regulators attempt to balance investor protection with the principles of decentralization. Finally, temporary exemptions for asset issuance are likely to emerge, providing issuers with a short-term reprieve to adapt to new requirements.

From my perspective, this scenario carries both risks and opportunities. On one hand, the absence of a unified law will heighten legal uncertainty for businesses, especially for small startups that struggle to navigate the conflicting requirements of two agencies. On the other hand, it could serve as a catalyst for more flexible and adaptive regulation that responds more quickly to technological innovation than the sluggish legislative process.

Ultimately, the market is entering a phase where every statement from the SEC or CFTC will be of critical importance. Investors and industry participants should prepare for volatility driven by regulatory news and closely monitor agency actions in the coming quarters.