French hardware wallet manufacturer Ledger has found itself at the center of an unexpected scandal. Although the company's devices were not directly affected by the recent hack that impacted Canadian Coldcard wallets from Coinkite, a wave of distrust and panic among users has hit the brand's reputation. Calls for a boycott and mass withdrawal of funds from "French" wallets are already circulating on social media. Let's figure out what actually happened.
The trigger was an incident involving Coldcard cold wallets, in which attackers stole 1367 BTC. However, as is often the case in the crypto community, panic quickly spread to other popular devices, including Ledger products. Notably, accusations against the French company are being made without any substantial evidence.
Baseless accusations and post-mortem analysis
Well-known crypto blogger MDX urged his followers to urgently withdraw funds from Ledger devices, calling the company "fraudulent." As proof, he published photos of a disassembled wallet, supposedly a Ledger Flex model. The images show the internal part of the device with the cover removed and a swollen battery cell.
The blogger claimed "external interference" and even asserted that traces of an attacker remained on the device. However, attentive commenters quickly identified the issue: this is standard degradation of a lithium-ion battery, which caused the cover to push out of the housing. Many users accused MDX of hidden advertising for a competitor — Trezor wallets, which he proposed as the only alternative.
Differences in security architecture
In response to the wave of criticism, Ledger published an official statement emphasizing that the Coldcard issue has nothing to do with them. The key difference lies in random number generation. In Ledger devices, the entropy generator is built directly into the protected Secure Element chip, ensuring a full 256 bits of entropy for each seed phrase. In Coldcard, on the other hand, the software generator from MicroPython was compromised, compressing the search space to 40 bits and making the wallets vulnerable to hacking.
Ledger's firmware remains closed-source, but its security is confirmed by third-party certifications, including AIS-31 standards, Common Criteria EAL5+ and EAL6+, as well as the CSPN scheme from the French agency ANSSI. Meanwhile, Coldcard relied on open-source code, and the error that had existed in the public repository since March 2021 was only discovered by Coinkite on the day of the theft.
My analysis: This incident is a vivid example of how information noise and panic can cause more damage than the technical threat itself. For investors, this is an important lesson: before giving in to emotional calls on social media, it is worth conducting your own fact-checking and relying on independent security audits rather than unverified claims from bloggers.