The quantum race has reached a new level: export controls have transformed from a simple defensive tool into a powerful lever of industrial strategy. This is confirmed by a fresh analysis that I have carefully studied. It is not just about attempts to restrict competitors' access, but about the deliberate shaping of the future architecture of the entire quantum industry.
Preemptive deterrence: a new approach to restrictions
My analysis shows that the United States and its allies operate on the principle of "preemptive deterrence." This is a fundamentally new approach: restrictions are imposed not when the technology has already matured and entered the market, but at early stages of development. The key point is that the focus has shifted from finished quantum computers to components and knowledge: cryogenic equipment, isotopically enriched silicon-28, control electronics, and even software.
Particular attention is drawn to "bottlenecks" in supply chains. For example, superconducting quantum systems require cooling to temperatures close to absolute zero. Such systems are produced on an industrial scale by only a few companies—Finland's Bluefors and the UK's Oxford Instruments. Such critical points allow licensing restrictions to be applied with maximum effectiveness, since no single country controls the entire supply chain.
The flip side of barriers
However, I am convinced that export controls are a double-edged sword. They can slow down development, but not stop it. The wider the supplier base, the more restrictions act as a source of delays and additional costs rather than a complete ban. Moreover, barriers spur competitors to create their own analogues. Chinese organizations, for example, have already accelerated work on domestic dilution refrigerators and materials for quantum applications.
In this regard, the key question is not "what to ban," but "which nodes of one's own ecosystem to support." Restrictions by themselves do not guarantee leadership. They must be combined with industrial policy, investment screening, and support for strategically important companies.
China bets on standards
It is telling that Beijing is betting not only on technology, but also on standardization. In June, China's Ministry of Industry and Information Technology established the quantum information standardization committee MIIT/TC10. It will focus on developing industry standards for foundational quantum technologies, computing, communication, and high-precision measurement.
This fits into a broader strategy: China is developing not only research, but also technical rules for commercialization. Standards are critical for equipment interoperability, terminology, testing, and procurement. At the international level, they allow influence over how future technologies will be designed and used. Earlier, analysts at the Special Competitive Studies Project already noted that the United States retains a slight advantage over China, but the gap is rapidly narrowing.
My professional conclusion: the quantum race increasingly resembles the Cold War in semiconductors. Export controls are just the tip of the iceberg. The real battle will be over standards, talent, and the industrial base. And in this battle, victory will go to those who can build a sustainable ecosystem, not just erect barriers.